Article Type : Review Article
Authors : Nuzzaci A
Keywords : Cultural heritage; Disasters; Catastrophic event; Earthquake; School; Teaching; Post-catastrophe
Catastrophic events are moments when people experience
major life transitions that challenge their identity and involve them
emotionally. Based on a systematic analysis of the literature, the paper
focuses on describing the results of an exploratory research conducted with
teachers who have experienced a catastrophic event (earthquake) and on the role
that environmental heritage and education can play in the post-disaster
recovery phase as a resource for teaching and community reconstruction. The
study involved 23 primary school teachers from Abruzzo who had experienced the
earthquake in an Italian context. The study used the semi-structured interview
technique to allow an in-depth analysis of the issues raised, based on
stimulating questions and related feedback. The results confirm that cultural
heritage possesses vital ganglia that can help people redefine the cultural,
social, perceptual and inhabited space, conceived as a socially constructed
territory, and strengthen those coping skills that help individuals recover
from the traumatic event and identify protective strategies that counteract the
existential disorientation that pervades them. This would facilitate
post-disaster recovery and mutual understanding between people in ways that
enhance their ability to accept loss and transform it into an experiential
resource. In essence, the study demonstrates how heritage in the post-disaster
phase can help teachers and students to rebuild their personal, social and
cultural community identity.
In the face of a pandemic or a catastrophic event such
as an earthquake, tsunami, etc., individuals' personal and social worlds are
overwhelmed, creating forms of "existential displacement" that lead
them to completely rethink the meaning of their actions and their lives.
Studies show how disasters can hinder the achievement of personal, educational
and professional goals, making people more vulnerable. Indeed, catastrophic
events have a strong emotional, behavioural and educational impact on
individuals, especially children and adolescents [1]. Post-catastrophic moments
therefore produce a great deal of disorientation in children, adolescents and
adults, leading them to redefine the conditions of continuous learning and
adaptation and to resort to different forms of coping (where they exist) in
order not to risk being overwhelmed by events. This is also because, after the
first moments of uncertainty, the crisis of the individual is also expressed at
the level of identity, in the form of a "relational and social loss",
which must be sustained through the provision of effective educational
interventions capable of rebuilding and keeping alive an experiential, cultural
and social fabric that appears lost or altered in the perception of the
individual.
Disasters also disrupt the essential social functions
of communities, creating forms of human and social disruption to which
communities may or may not be able to respond, as resilience research has
shown. In fact, successful communities also increase their ability to network
and respond to relief efforts, i.e. to be resilient [2,3]. In fact, when a
critical event occurs, it is possible that incisive and positive relational
responses from individuals, organizations and local groups will occur, leading
to emergency management before and during the event. These responses can also
relate to the symbols and meanings that cultural and environmental heritage
brings, which help to reconnect individuals with the community to which they
belong, increasing the enjoyment of life and the desire to support the
community, with the idea that the sharing of signs and meanings can make it
possible to cope with and overcome crises. This is in order to initiate new
identity processes that lead the community to participate in a true "multi-identity"
re-foundation. In recent years, a body of theoretical and empirical research
has begun to explore and document more systematically the role that cultural
and environmental heritage plays in the preventive and post-disaster phases in
helping children, young people, families, schools and organizations to cope
with moments of crisis before, during and after a disaster. In this sense, the
theme of territorial, cultural and environmental heritage seems to be
fundamental in the search for significant forms of intervention in the
post-disaster phase that best support students in their journey to overcome the
difficulties of the critical event, which can have lasting effects helping them
to reconnect the "before" and the "after" of the
catastrophic event [4,5]. In the field of education, these situations represent
real existential and formative challenges, where teachers are called upon to
redefine their professionalism through precise forms of reflection and to
prepare interventions aimed at strengthening the learning paths of students at
different levels.
One wonders, therefore, how it is possible for a
teacher, from the moment of the disaster, to continue to create authentic
learning opportunities for all pupils and to support them in their progressive
recovery, given the existential displacement that overwhelms them. Indeed, in
post-disaster crises, life skills and literacy processes are put to the test
and the school population is exposed to conditions of high literacy risk, but
also to the weakening of the set of social, cognitive and personal skills that
would be necessary to face the needs and challenges of daily life in a positive
way. This often has a radical impact on students' thoughts, behaviours and
attitudes [6]. Literacy, understood as the repertoire of basic knowledge and
skills that individuals need to live in a rapidly changing world and which is
an indispensable condition for their continued participation in social,
cultural, political and economic activities, is at risk of being compromised as
a result of a disruptive event, such as a natural disaster, which interrupts
the acquisition process. However, if it is understood as "living
literacy", it tends to encompass the way people write and read about their
lives , thus including their individual, social, cultural and environmental
heritage, which constitute those symbolic and identity elements that
distinguish a given community and a given territory in its various aspects
(historical, artistic, archaeological, architectural, environmental,
ethno-anthropological, etc.) [7,8]. Post-disaster prevention and educational
intervention programs based on community and community literacy can effectively
reduce conditions such as depression, anxiety and loneliness. This is because
vulnerability implies the notion of 'risk education', in which individuals and
communities are able to perceive and interpret the difficulties they are
exposed to in a 'fragile' environment, and make appropriate choices arising
from this awareness. Continuing to create authentic learning opportunities for
students, without interrupting the development of literacy processes
(cognitive, relational, social, etc.), therefore becomes fundamental for their
growth and life. At the heart of this concept is a form of knowledge that allows
students to integrate literacy processes at deep levels of their personality
and reality, and teachers to significantly restructure their professionalism by
adopting pedagogical strategies that allow them to help their students
understand "who they are and what they are" [9,8]. However, literacy
is an essential human right and a real "treasure" that cannot be
neglected without risking inevitably generating a whole series of collateral
problems that affect individuals and, in post-disaster situations, aggravate
the situation of the most vulnerable groups [10]. It is necessary to implement
structured socio-educational interventions to counteract the disorientation and
discomfort caused by the "losses" resulting from the traumatic event.
Therefore, if it is true that, over time, literacy has become an essential tool
for improving the lives of individuals and eliminating inequalities through the
development of virtuous policies and practices aimed at overcoming problems of
various kinds, it is necessary to clarify the relationship between literacy,
emergency and individual, social, cultural and environmental assets. For this
reason, in the post-disaster phase, the cultural and environmental assets and
resources of a territory can be interpreted as real "lifelines"
capable of providing valid support for learning and the activation of coping
strategies capable of supporting, through their diversity, the need to rebuild
the identities of a given territorial community.
In recent years, the literature has sought to explain
how the use of cultural heritage in education plays a crucial role in improving
disaster resilience. Cultural and environmental assets and resources contribute
significantly to post-disaster recovery by restoring cultural identity and
helping students develop coping strategies to deal with stressful events and
the risk to children's emotional health, particularly post-traumatic stress
disorder (PTSD) and its symptoms [11]. The inclusion of post-disaster
educational pathways can ensure sustainability and promote effective responses
[12]. Integrating cultural heritage into educational risk management in
vulnerable areas is essential to managing uncertainty in educational settings.
By recognising the importance of cultural heritage in disaster response and
preparedness, educational programmes can harness knowledge and skills to build
community resilience and facilitate faster recovery [13-15]. In this sense,
cultural heritage plays a crucial role in the post-disaster phase by
contributing to individual and community resilience and to the progressive
personal recovery and overall well-being [16,17]. Although countries such as
Italy have not always emphasised disaster-related preventive measures, in
recent years cultural and natural heritage has been widely recognised as a
powerful resilience tool in the post-disaster phase. In the aftermath of a
disaster, in addition to rescuing people, it is also necessary to rescue their
cultural heritage; such a mutual rescue allows for a faster recovery and
improves the resilience of individuals in the long term, but also to generate
benefits of various kinds during reconstruction, contributing to social
transformation and reducing social vulnerability [18]. In particular, the
integration of cultural heritage in educational contexts can provide a platform
for learning from the past, fostering a sense of identity and promoting
individual and community engagement. This idea not only safeguards cultural and
environmental heritage, but also equips people with the knowledge and skills
they need to recover from disasters, ultimately contributing to overall
resilience in challenging circumstances.
The individual's struggle to regain his or her
identity mobilises the territory as a vital space for the implementation of
concrete actions. The various educational institutions are therefore urged to
develop a clear strategic framework after a disaster in order to try to promote
actions at local level to combat school disaffection, dropping out, etc., due
to these difficulties, which require different practices of socio-educational
support. It is not easy to define the territory as an operational level on
which to graft the various educational tools aimed at preventing and resolving
the existential displacement of individuals in the post-disaster phase even if
such a conception requires precise strategies that are useful for countering
it, focusing attention both on the way people appropriate the cultural and
environmental resources available in a given territory and on the training
opportunities that can be created at all levels, especially in terms of
teaching quality [16]. Didactic strategies based on the use of cultural
heritage go precisely in this direction, in order to remove the obstacles to
learning resulting from "catastrophes" that also become
"individual, cultural and social" and risk deeply undermining the
identity of a given community. Indeed, the negative effects of territorial
fragility on the perception of individuals could be curbed by implementing
educational processes aimed at reconstructing individual, cultural and social
memory and identity. For this to happen, however, it is essential to ask
whether and to what extent such assets can help students stem the lack of
certainty caused by disorientation [19]. A study carried out at the University
of L'Aquila has brought this link into focus, highlighting how a catastrophic
event such as an earthquake has a negative impact on students' perceptions of
school dropout and lack of well-being, and how effective educational solutions
that can be traced back to cultural and environmental heritage can have a
significant positive impact on reducing discomfort [16]. These solutions have
been shown to work well, complementing and reinforcing routine educational
interventions. Although they can be considered as stand-alone strategies, they
have been shown to have an impact on student learning, with more positive
outcomes in the presence of improvement plans and specific instructional design
modules, as also observed in the evidence literature.
Based on a systematic
review of the literature, the objectives of the study are to explore
A. The
opinions and perceptions of teachers who have experienced a catastrophic event
(earthquake) about the role that heritage and environmental education can play
in the post-disaster recovery phase as a resource for teaching and community
rebuilding;
B. The
opinions and perceptions of teachers who have experienced a catastrophic event
(earthquake) about strategies related to heritage education that can be used in
the post-disaster phase to help students recover.
The literature suggests that cultural and
environmental heritage plays a crucial role in education and post-disaster
recovery. When catastrophic events such as earthquakes, wars or natural
disasters occur, communities may lose not only human lives and infrastructure,
but also fundamental parts of their cultural identity. In this sense, education
becomes a vital means of preserving the history, traditions, assets and
cultural practices of the vulnerable community. Schools play a crucial role in
the post-disaster recovery process by helping to harness cultural and environmental
assets to keep the memory of affected communities alive, build resilience and
restore a sense of cultural belonging. Heritage education in a post-disaster
context can take many forms, contributing to the preservation of history,
environment and culture with the aim of promoting healing and social cohesion
in affected communities. Conversely, heritage education can also contribute to
the prevention of future disasters by helping teachers to find ways and forms
of education that enable students to understand the importance of preserving
and protecting cultural and environmental heritage, with a greater awareness
and responsibility for their own cultural heritage and the natural environment.
The study adopted the qualitative approach and made use
of interview and descriptive approaches to gather and present data.
Participants
The study involved 23 primary school teachers from
Abruzzo who had experienced the earthquake in an Italian context. The
interviewees were selected on the basis of availability and precise
characteristics (age, teaching level, etc.). The semi-structured interview
technique was used in the study in order to allow a more in-depth exploration
of the issues raised, starting from stimulating questions and the corresponding
feedback. The participants ranged in age from 47 to 57 and were all primary
school teachers. All participants had experienced the earthquake that struck
the city of L'Aquila in 2009. The interviews took place twelve years after the
disaster. In this sense, the interviews were also used in a retrospective sense
as a research tool to obtain detailed information about past experiences and
perceptions of the L'Aquila area [20].
This type of interview was particularly useful in understanding the value and relationship between cultural heritage, disaster contexts and teaching from different perspectives, in terms of
Data were collected through interviews and participant observation. An interview guide was used and interviewers contacted stakeholders directly who had direct experience of the earthquake and who were in a role.
The transcription, coding and analysis of the data was carried out using Nvivo software, which enabled qualitative analysis of the data through the use of a codebook, facilitated by the use of the software. A thematic analysis was carried out, together with a semantic analysis, which enabled the extraction of macro-categories and sub-categories, which helped to make the respondents' answers more interpretable.
Category
The study confirmed what has already been highlighted in some preliminary studies on areas of vulnerability [16], namely that cultural and environmental heritage can play a key role in promoting community resilience after a disaster. In the teachers' opinions and perceptions, the categorised elements mainly concerned the role of heritage in post-disaster education processes [21-23]. The main categories on the two axes are listed below:
The role
of cultural and environmental heritage education in post-disaster recovery
From the interviews, it emerges that, in the teachers' view, cultural heritage constitutes an important pillar of resilience both for students and for the entire school community after a disaster, offering a solid foundation for the reconstruction of identity, for the restoration of a certain normality, the recovery of stability and social-emotional, relational, cognitive well-being, etc., as well as for the preparation of their future.
Strategies related to cultural
and environmental heritage education
In
education, heritage education can play a significant role in promoting
different coping skills within a school community after a disaster. Teachers
clearly indicate some supportive strategies related to cultural and
environmental heritage grouped in:
In the light of the results, it can be seen that for
the teachers interviewed, the importance of designing and implementing
effective strategies that enable students to use and enjoy cultural heritage to
cope with the difficulties related to post-disaster concerns:
The teachers interviewed are convinced that activating
quality literacy processes by making use of local assets and resources before,
during and after a disaster is an arduous task, which is not without its
difficulties, but which they believe is indispensable in order to be able to
help pupils cope with the difficulties, crises and challenges that communities
and the environment present to them on a daily basis. It remains very difficult
for teachers to activate quality teaching processes in a crisis situation and
to search for the meanings of what is happening, has happened or will happen
and its implications. However, they consider it essential to try to help
students understand, using cultural and environmental heritage as a resource, so
that they can continue to learn to manage their own thoughts and emotions.
Finally, some participants emphasise how the experience of catastrophic events
leaves an indelible mark on people's lives and on the cultural and social
context in which they live, opening up internal and external fissures that make
them more vulnerable to subsequent critical events. In addition, respondents
argue that catastrophic events such as the earthquake challenge teachers'
entire repertoire of skills, forcing them to confront, both during and after
the disaster, a range of issues related to the ability to manage uncertainty in
everyday school life. In essence, for teachers, heritage can support students
in learning to use their knowledge and skills to resolve identity issues, such
as a sense of belonging, to activate appropriate decision-making processes, to
provide rational explanations of catastrophic phenomena, to avoid the
temptation to give in to fatalism and to feel useless in relation to what can
be constructed as false beliefs [24].
The study sought to explore the opinions and
perceptions of teachers who experienced the 2009 L'Aquila earthquake to
understand the relationship between cultural and environmental heritage,
disaster events and teaching. The study revealed the importance of using
heritage to strengthen coping skills and restore everyday normality, which
created existential voids for students. Heritage education in schools is an
important aspect of learning that helps students understand and appreciate the
diversity and richness of their local resources, with the idea of fostering a
sense of identity and belonging among students, as well as promoting respect
for other cultures. These experiences enable students to learn new concepts and
skills in a more engaging and meaningful way. However, catastrophic events such
as natural disasters can have a significant impact on the ability of schools to
provide education, including heritage education. Such events can result in the
destruction of educational infrastructure, displacement of communities and
disruption of schooling, with long-term effects on student learning and
well-being. To mitigate the impact of disasters on education, it is important
that schools have disaster management plans in place and integrate recovery and
learning approaches. This will ensure that education, including heritage
education, can continue with minimal disruption during and after such events.
This was also emphasised by respondents. It was clear from the study that
teachers see the school as a learning environment where cultural and
environmental heritage is a source of knowledge and a tool for resilience.
Teachers state that, in the face of catastrophic
events, it becomes crucial to develop well-structured training interventions
aimed at supporting students' efforts to reduce, mitigate and positively manage
post-traumatic stress to enable them to accelerate recovery, maintain
relationships with others, improve coping skills, recover from adversity,
prepare for possible future experiences and adapt effectively to adversity. At
the same time, however, they emphasize the need to provide teachers with
training opportunities to recover and improve their teaching practice through
professional learning paths that enable them to deal with such problematic
situations. This is in line with what has already emerged in the literature.
Although research does not always agree on which types of intervention are most
effective in emergency and post-disaster situations, there seems to be a
general consensus that one of the most effective ways to improve educational
support during or after disasters is to support through training those who work
directly with children and young people, who often report feeling unprepared to
deal with complex situations [25, 26]. In this sense, the interviewees
emphasize the lack of a culture of education, which involves territorial and
community aspects, indicating how cultural heritage plays a central role in
fostering identity re-foundation.
The study highlighted the teachers' conviction that
cultural and environmental assets and territorial resources can facilitate the
recognition of one's own community and sense of belonging, and can contribute
to teachers' taking charge of pupils' difficulties, especially in the early
educational intervention phase, i.e. in the first moments after the occurrence
of the disaster, when assets appear to pupils as a source of rootedness,
anchoring and refunding typical of human beings and citizens. Teachers
emphasise how the identification of information from different sources and the
critical analysis of its veracity can help them to maintain their awareness of
spaces and environments. The study confirms what some previous studies have highlighted,
that assets can redirect learning towards what is 'desirable' and reorient
students' engagement with what they do and who they are. Indeed, teachers' main
concerns are how best to support pupils' learning when much of their confidence
has been undermined by uncertainty, how to continue to nurture in them a desire
to learn and to make good use of knowledge and literacy processes (in the
present and future situation) and, above all, how to encourage them to
rediscover and maintain a focus on life through cultural and environmental
assets, which can be said to be fundamental to a broad concept of “belonging”.
Heritage education can be a powerful teaching tool to
help students and school communities overcome the trauma of disaster by helping
to equip individuals with the personal, cultural and social resources needed to
cope effectively and constructively, but only if teachers in post-disaster
settings are themselves supported in the arduous task of 'teaching' in
emergency contexts. Consequently,
teacher training in resilience skills should be conceived of as 'resisting'
hazards and managing risk, rather than avoiding them, and should aim at the
acquisition of concrete coping strategies. Cultural and environmental heritage
education, adopted as a risk management tool, is essential to increase the
capacity to understand catastrophic and pandemic phenomena in order to
intervene more precisely and incisively at the local level and reduce negative
impacts. This highlights the importance of supporting teachers in local
contexts by looking to resources outside the school as a valuable resource.
School communities facing crisis situations require a rapid response from
different stakeholders, requiring decision-making, planning and foresight skills
that, if not present, could expose them to serious risks. Learning to identify
resources and assets outside the school and having appropriate skills to deal
with a 'crisis' therefore becomes the best defence in understanding the
consequences it could have on the school population if not properly managed
[27-47].