Article Type : Research Article
Authors : Cani A, Gradica F, Kokiçi F and Agolli L
Keywords : PEEP; PaO2; Mechanical ventilation; ARDS
Introduction: ARDS is defined as pulmonary inflammatory process characterized by increased capillary permeability associated with acute severe hypoxemia and bilateral infiltrates on the chest radiograph. Clinical manifestations of ARDS is associated with a reduction of functional residual capacity and static compliance of the respiratory system. Recently, after experimental models and physiological studies have just established the principles to understand the potential beneficial effects of PEEP and reduction in mortality to 22%. The benefit of PEEP has been demonstrated in terms of preventing cyclic opening and collapsing alveoli in acute respiratory distress syndrome patients (ARDS).
Aim of study: To determine the appropriate PEEP level in-patients with ARDS. Objective: By using optimal PEEP: to realize the maximal alveolar recruitment. To avoid the decrease of oxygen delivery (DO2) as result of an unfavourable reduction in cardiac output.
Material and methods: Retrospective study of 120 patients which only 63 of them are included in study with age 18-70 years old (2012-2014). The entry criteria were clinically (severe dyspnoea, tachypnea, cyanosis); PaO2/FiO2 <200mmHG, the presence of bilateral chest infiltrates. The exclusion criteria were: aged < 18 yrs. COPD in history of diseases, heart attack; PEEP was set the level that provided the greatest improvement in oxygenation. The optimal PEEP came as a result of gradual increase of PEEP from 2-5 cm H2O every 6 hours, depended on gas analyses. The right PEEP level is the PEEP allowing the highest PaO2 value without causing hemodynamic compromise.
Results: During this study we conclude that the gradual increase of PEEP improves significantly arterial oxygen tension (PaO2). Per value of PEEP 9.6-15.8, CI 95% is 145.9-191.8. The Pearson test with a significant correlation coefficient of level 0.995 and significance level 0.000 shows also a very important result. It was considered significant statistically the value of P? 0.05. Also the value of Chi ² of PaO2 and of PEEP, has resulted significant in 0.950 with P < 0.001.
Conclusion: Mechanical ventilation using optimal PEEP increases the value of PaO2. As a matter of fact 88% of cases with PaO2 > 220 mmHg survive. The role of PEEP in clinical practice is still debated but, in selected categories of patients with a careful monitoring, it may play an important role in improving outcome.
Modern
artificial ventilation (AV) has started since 60 years. First time it has been
used by Danish doctors, when the country was hit by the polio epidemic of 1952
to 1953 years. The problem of lung congestion, "stiff-lung" was
resolved. In Europe this method spread very quickly. AV few months allowed to
be treated successfully in cases of alveolar hypoventilation in patients with
neuromuscular coma and barbiturates [1-4]. A new era began in the late fifties,
when AV was applied on patients with decompensate chronic obstructive pulmonary
disease, which lead to respiratory encephalopathy almost always lethal. Changes
in the early sixties took place. There are many studies and surveys published
cases of acute respiratory distress syndrome with different etiologies [5-6].
1967 ASHBAUGH and his colleagues regrouped under the term "Adult
Respiratory Distress Syndrome” (ARDS); they proposed a single interpretation
that allows integration of all clinical [7], radiological, evolutionary and
anatomical different state such as acute respiratory failure, acute viral
pneumonia, the embolism from fats, acute pancreatitis, the toxic coma etc [8].
This
new treatment of ARDS proposed maintaining a positive pressure. In Albania
patients with ARDS were diagnosed in early 1982-1983. It was necessary to
formulate a clear definition of the syndrome. Such a definition was developed
in 1994 by the American-European Consensus Conference (AECC) on Acute
Respiratory Distress Syndrome (ARDS). The term “acute respiratory distress
syndrome” was used instead of “adult respiratory distress syndrome” because the
syndrome occurs in both adults and children, ARDS is a syndrome that commonly
begins after exposure to a known risk factor. Why some people develop ARDS and
others do not is still unknown. The risk factors for ARDS include primary
pulmonary etiologies (aspiration, pneumonia, toxic inhalation, pulmonary
contusion) and extra pulmonary etiologies (sepsis, pancreatitis, multiple blood
transfusions, trauma, and use of drugs such as heroin). Sometimes, ARDS is not
only a reaction to another event but also the result of a known cause, such as
an acute interstitial pneumonia (AIP) or a severe, extensive, infectious
pneumonia [9-12]. In 2012, the ARDS Definition Task Force met in Berlin and
decided on a new and improved definition of ARDS using 3 mutually exclusive
categories of ARDS based on the degree of hypoxemia:
·
Mild: PaO2/FIO 2 ? 300 mm Hg but > 200 mm Hg
·
Moderate: PaO2/FIO 2 ? 200 mm Hg but > 100 mm Hg
·
Severe: PaO2/FIO 2 ?100 mm Hg
The
Berlin Definition outlines stages of mild, moderate, and severe ARDS as
associated with increased mortality and increased duration of mechanical
ventilation in survivors and was found to be more predictive than the prior
AECC definition [13-16]. Mild, moderate, and severe ARDS were associated with
increased mortality rates (27%, 32%, and 45%, respectively; P < .001) and
increased median duration of mechanical ventilation in survivors (5, 7, and 9
days; P < .001). Four ancillary variables for severe ARDS, to include
radiographic severity, respiratory system compliance (?40 ml/cm water),
positive end-expiratory pressure (?10 cm water), and corrected expired volume
per minute (?10 L/min), were not predictive, and it was decided to drop them
from the definition [17-18].
To
determine the optimal level of PEEP in order to achieve a maximal alveolar recruitment
through the appropriate levels of oxygenation.
Material and Methods
Of
the 120 patients in the study they were included 63 of them aged 18-70 years
admitted to the Intensive Care Service of Pulmonary and Critical Care of the
polyvalent University Hospital Centre, Tirana during 2012-2014. Inclusion
criteria of patients with ARDS defined by clinical data (severe dyspnea,
tachypnea, cyanosis). Arterial blood gas shows refractory hypoxemia
progressively. PaO2 / FiO2 <200 mmHg; X-ray examination with bilateral
diffuse alveolar infiltration; Exclusion criteria; Patients with chronic
obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), previous myocardial infarction,
neuromuscular disease that may impair breathing, patients with hemodynamic
instability, patients operated by pneumonectomy, lobectomy, pulmonary biopsy,
patients with pneumothorax (PNX), patients with pulmonary hypertension,
patients aged under 18 years.
Statistical Analysis
Processing of
the obtained results is made by the method of analysis of variance (ANOVA)
using SPSS14, statistical program (Statistical Program for Social Sciences). In
statistical processing are determined by Pearson correlation initial PaO2
values, lower PaO2, best PaO2 and highest PEEP giving the average, standard
deviation, and the average standard error. Also by standard deviation is done
with Pearson correlation to determine the initial values of shunt, shunt with
minimal PEEP, and shunt with maximum PEEP. Also this correlation are determined
values of DO2 (delivery of oxygen) and PEEP, CF (cardiac frequency) and PEEP,
MAP (mean arterial pressure) and PEEP. To evaluate the relationship between the
values of PaO2 and PEEP are performed statistical analysis: average, the error
standard and error average of deviation standard. (One Sample Statistics) and
(One Sample Test which sets t statistic, is significant, the average error and
confidence interval (95% CI) values of probability (P value). It is evaluated
as statistically significant P?0.05. Also to evaluate the link between the values
of PaO2 and PEEP correlation of Pearson and CHI2 test (Chi Square) were
performed. For the initial values of PaO2, lower PaO2, best of PaO2 and highest
PEEP value were performed by Pearson correlation too. Correlation of 0995 shows
that it is significant at the level of values 0.01. Whereas higher chi square
test shows that this values are reliable. Also these values are presented in
Box plot (distribution of variance around the average).
Presentation
of the PaO2 values and the number of patients in the table presented by
Survival and PaO2 shows the PaO2 initial values, PaO2 lower values and higher
PaO2. Processing of these statistical study therefore PaO2 values and PEEP is
presented in the following table which sets out the average, standard deviation
and average deviation error standard. (One Sample Statistic). Presentation of
statistical values, is significant and 95% confidence interval is given in the
following table (One Sample Test) (Figures 1-5).
Respiratory distress syndrome is a pulmonary inflammatory disease characterized by pulmonary edema, bilateral pulmonary infiltration and refractory hypoxemia. ARDS clinical manifestations are associated with reduced functional residual capacity and static compliance (Tables 1-5). Epidemiological data are linked with etiology; mortality, including cause of death, the presence of any other vital organ failure and improving of pulmonary function and quality of life. The lack of a specific therapy in ARDS is associated with high morbidity and mortality and pose a significant financial burden for human health care. Therefore from different studies on patients with ARDS, recognition of physiopathology mechanisms with inflammatory process in the early stages of the disease and fibro-proliferative stage in advanced stages of the disease, require the determination of strategies and supportive therapy, having as main objective the reduction of morbidity, mortality and improving the quality of life.
Although
care for the treatment of ARDS has improved in recent decades, few studies have
shown that a particular treatment may reduce mortality of this deadly syndrome.
In recent editions of the New England Medical Journal was demonstrated
strategies of pulmonary ventilation to minimize lung damage and reduce
mortality by 22%.An important issue in publications made for ARDS is:
"What is important in recruitment manoeuvre and
how to determine an optimal setting (of appropriate PEEP in patients with
ARDS).The pressure / volume (p / v) curve in the respiratory system plays a
central role in developing the concept of pulmonary protection and offers a
unique opportunity to assess alveolar recruitment / de recruitment. This
information can be useful to characterize the stage of the disease and the
identification optimal PEEP regime in ventilator, making the pressure / volume
curve a valuable tool for the treatment of respiratory acute pulmonary
impairment in ARDS.
The use of recruitment maneuvers
and high PEEP is a fairly good way of ventilation in patients with ARDS. It is
important to note that gaseous exchange parameters were evaluated as prognostic
factors in response of using PEEP. It is observed that the improvement of the
PaO2 values in ??24 hours after application of PEEP it is quite significant in
patients who survive.In fact, 88% of patients with PaO2 value > 220 mmHg
survive. MV with PEEP can not be considered as a solution to all hypoxemia
severe cases, however, it allows number of patients with ARDS to survive,
because without it they would not survive. The role of PEEP in
clinical practice is still debatable but, in selected categories of patients
with a careful monitoring, it may play an important role in improving outcome.
Abbreviation
AV: Artificial Ventilation; MV:
Mechanical Ventilation; ALI:
Acute Lung Injury; ARDS: Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome; ARM: Alveolar
Recruitment Manoeuvre; Fio2: Inspired Fracture of Oxygen; PEEP:
Positive End-Expiratory Pressure; Paco2: Partial Arterial Pressure
of Carbon Dioxide; Pao2: Partial Arterial Pressure of Oxygen; Sao2:
Arterial Oxygen Saturation; VT: Tidal Volume.; P/V: Pressure /Volume
Curve; CF: Cardiac Frequency; DO2: Delivery of Oxygen; FRC: Functional Residual
Capacity
2.
Gattinoni
L, Pelosi P, Suter PM, Pedoto A, Vercesi P, Lissoni A. Acute respiratory distress
syndrome caused by pulmonary and extrapulmonary disease. Different syndromes?
Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 1998; 158: 3-11.