Article Type : Research Article
Authors : Cintra Michelle V, da Cunha Daltro CH, Cavalcanti Soares JL, Bitencourt Powell B and Cavalcante Castro MM
Keywords : Acromegaly; Quality of life; Comparative study; Clinical aspects
Objective: To compare the
health-related quality of life (HRQL) of acromegalics with healthy individuals
and to investigate factors predictive of HRQL.
Design: Observational study
with a comparison group. Patients from an endocrinology referral center
attended from 2014 to 2017 were selected. The HRQL was evaluated using the
Short Form Health Survey 36 (SF-36) and the Acromegaly Quality of Life
Questionnaire (AcroQol).
Main Outcome Measures:
Acromegalic patients have lower HRQL than healthy individuals, and psychiatric
disorders are associated with a reduction in the HRQL of these patients.
Socioeconomic factors can also impact quality of life.
Results: A 71 acromegalic
patients and 76 healthy individuals were studied. Patient scores were much
lower and ranged from 25% to 50% of the values from the comparison group.
Patients' scores were comparable to the healthy Brazilian geriatric population,
with a mean age of 28 years older. The median of the AcroQol inventory result
was 53.4 (28.4-68.1) and the only clinical variable associated with low scores
in this inventory was the presence of psychiatric disorders even after adjusted
for sex (p= 0.021).
Conclusion: Acromegalic
patients have HRQL more compromised than the healthy population and psychiatric
aspects have a factor of worsening of HRQL. Mental health monitoring should be
implemented in neuroendocrinology services, in favor of improving HRQL.
Acromegaly manifests
itself with physical deformities and multiple systemic complications, being
more common between 35 and 50 years of age [1-5]. Individuals with acromegaly
have a reduced life expectancy at 5 years compared to healthy people [5,6]. The
HRQL of acromegalic patients was lower than that of the healthy population,
mainly due to decreased work activity, chronic pain, psychological and
psychiatric disorders, sexual problems, and discomfort with self-image [7-18].
These aspects are commonly associated with changes in growth hormone (GH) [19].
The orofacial alterations caused by acromegaly, such as prognathism and
macroglossia, compromise socialization and self-esteem [9-18]. Thus, changes in
self-image were associated with high scores for anxiety and depression, low
self-esteem, poor HRQL scores, and emotional apathy for acromegalic patients
[20]. Even if treated, these patients present alterations, which suggest that
the effect of GH excess on the central nervous system can be long-lasting and
even irreversible. As such, this study aims to describe the quality of life
(QoL) of patients with acromegaly, to compare them to healthy individuals
(comparative group) and to investigate the predictors of patients' HRQL.
This is an Observational
study with a comparison group performed at a reference centre in Endocrinology
and Diabetes in Brazil from 2014 to 2017. To evaluate the impact of acromegaly
on the HRQL of affected patients, it was used a generic (Medical Outcomes
Study-36 Item Short Form Health Survey- SF-36) and specific questionnaire
(Acromegaly Quality of Life Questionnaire -AcroQol). The present study was
approved by the local Research Ethics Committee, under the number CAAE:
56840516.4.0000.5544. All research participants signed the Informed Consent
Form. The Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS, Armonk, NY, USA),
version 21.0 IBM® was used to analyse and tabulate the data. The categorical
variables were expressed by absolute and relative frequency, the continuous
variables by mean and standard deviation, and the scores by median and
interquartile range. The acromegalic group was divided according to the median
AcroQol scores (median = 53), to investigate the factors associated with HRQL
Student's t-tests, Mann Whitney, Pearson Chi-Square tests and Fisher exact test
were used to compare the groups. After the initial analysis, the variables that
showed a p-value < 0.20 between the groups divided according to the median
AcroQol scores, were adjusted in the logistic regression (psychiatric disturbs
and sex). P-values ? 0.05 were considered statiscally significant.
The sample consisted of 71 acromegalic patients and 76 healthy individuals. The groups were similar (Table 1).
Table 1: Sociodemographic
characteristics of 147 subjects studied.
Figure 1: Quality of life in the groups: mediano f scores of SF-36 (Mann-Whitney Test).
VARIABLE |
PATIENTS N = 71 |
COMPARISON GROUP N = 76 |
P |
Age* |
47.0 (±12,67) |
47.4 (±12,33) |
0.828 |
Feminine Gender † |
46 (64.8%) |
57(75.0%) |
0.177 |
Family Income† |
|||
0-1 0-1 Up to 1 Salary |
18 (25.4%) |
3 (3.9%) |
<0.001 |
? 2 Wages |
53 (74.6%) |
73 (96,1%) |
|
Residence† |
|||
Countryside |
24 (70.6%) |
23 (62.2%) |
0.002 |
Urban Area |
10 (29.4% ) |
14 (37.8%) |
|
* Results in
mean and standard deviation - T-test † Chi- Square Test |
Figure
1 compares the acromegalic scores with the comparison group. The median of the
patient's SF-36 scales ranged from 25% to 50% of the comparison group scores
(healthy). The median of the inventory result, AcroQol, was 53.4 (28.4-68.1).
Values of p < 0.001.
The clinical characteristics of patients are described in Table 2.
Table 2: Clinical characteristics in 71 acromegalic patients.
VARIABLE |
RESULTS |
Hypertension |
46 (64.3%) |
Dyslipidemia |
26 (37.1%) |
Diabetes |
40 (56.3%) |
Obesity |
24 (34.3%) |
Psychiatric
Disorders |
11 (15.5%) |
Carpal
Tunnel Syndrome |
2 (2.8%) |
Diagnostic
Time (years) * |
5 (2-10) |
Performed
Surgery for Tumor Removal |
57 (80.3%) |
Using
Somastatin Analogue |
53 (74.6%) |
Macroadenoma (> 1 cm) |
60 (92.3%) |
Uuncontrolled Disease |
58 (82.3%) |
* Results in the median and interquartile range |
The only variable associated with low inventory scores was psychiatric disorder (Table 3). Acromegalic patients who presented a psychiatric diagnosis in their medical records were affected mainly by depression in this study (Figure 2).
Table 3: Description of clinical variables of the 71 acromegalics, according to Quality of life (AcroQol) CEDEBA, Brazil, 2018.
|
AcroQol |
|
||
VARIABLE |
Md ? 53 |
Md > 53 |
p |
P-adjusted |
Age* |
47.4 (± 11.8) |
46.6 (± 13.5) |
0.802 |
0.25 |
Feminine Gender † |
25 (73.5%) |
21 (56.8%) |
0.139 |
|
Performed Surgery for Tumor Removal† |
25 (73.5%) |
32 (86.5%) |
0.235 |
|
Using Somastatin Analogue† |
23 (67.3%) |
30 (81.1%) |
0.276 |
0.036 |
Hypertension† |
21 (61.8%) |
24 (64.9%) |
0.81 |
|
Dyslipidemia† |
11 (32.4%) |
15 (40.5%) |
0.623 |
|
Diabetes† |
21 (61.8%) |
19 (51.4%) |
0.474 |
|
Obesity† |
12 (35.3%) |
13 (35.1%) |
1 |
|
Psychiatric Disorders† |
9.0 (26.5%) |
2 (5.4%) |
0.021 |
|
Diagnostic Time years) ‡ |
4.4 (1.0-10.3) |
6 (1.2-11.5) |
0.557 |
|
Macroadenoma § |
28 (93.3%) |
32 (91,4%) |
1 |
|
Family Income|| |
|
|
||
0-1 0-1 Up to 1 Salary |
10 (29.4%) |
8 (21.6%) |
0.451 |
|
? 2 Wages |
24 (70.6%) |
29 (78.4%) |
|
|
Residence|| |
|
|
||
Countryside |
24(70,6%) |
23 (62,2%) |
0.453 |
|
Urban Area |
10 (29,4%) |
14 (37,8%) |
|
|
* Results in mean and
standard deviation - T-test |
Figure 2: Psychiatric disorders presente in acromegalic patients (n=11).
This study showed that acromegalic patients have lower HRQL than healthy individuals, and that psychiatric disorders are associated with a reduction in the HRQL of these patients. Socioeconomic factors can also impact quality of life. Although the mean age of the sample was comprised of adults, the median SF-36 scores of the patients, when compared to the results of the Brazilian healthy population, were also lower, being similar to the data of the elderly age group i.e., above 75 years (healthy Brazilian population almost 28 years older), as illustrated below Figure 1. Therefore, it can be concluded that acromegaly has an impact on HRQL as well as on functional capacity, thus compromising and aging the health scores (Figure 3).
Figure 3: SF-36 scores of patients in the sample compared to the normative study of the Brazilian population (over 75 years).
Acromegalic patients
present more psychological complaints compared to other dimensions of health
[21,22]. The reduction of HRQL is predominantly driven by psychopathology
rather than other biochemical factors in acromegalic patients. In the present
study, the only clinical factor associated with HRQL reduction was the presence
of psychiatric issues, which corroborates findings from the literature. The
present study presented important differences between the control group and
patients, regarding emotional aspects and mental health (SF-36 domains), in
order to reiterate that acromegalic patients present more psychic suffering
than the general population. Regarding emotional aspects, the patients had a
median score that was 67% lower than the comparison group. The median mental
health of the patients was almost 32% lower than the median of the comparative
group. The mean AcroQol scores in the patient sample were lower in relation to
national and international studies, which may suggest interference with
sociodemographic aspects [23,24].
In addition to the
scientific implications, the clinical application of this research is the
finding that important predictors of decreased HRQL are the psychiatric
aspects, which are essentially modifiable predictors. Thus, mental health
monitoring should be implemented in neuroendocrinology services, in favour of
improving HRQL.
Acknowledgements
None
Declaration of Interest Statement
There is no conflict of
interest. This survey did not receive any specific grants from any public,
non-profit, or commercial funding agencies.