Article Type : Research Article
Authors : Helmeyer IP and Katafygiotis P
Keywords : Chronic stress; Anxiety; Depression; Post-traumatic stress disorder
If we are to decipher the biggest problem for citizens
living in large modern cosmopolitan cities, solving some daily problems at home
and at work or the psychopathology that accompany these problems, we would
certainly end up choosing the latter. In this review article, we would like to
present a functional hypothesis based on scientific articles that could
validate our hypothesis. Psychological distress emanating from accelerated
modern lifestyles is mainly due to the presence of chronic stress, anxiety, depression,
and post-traumatic stress disorder, which could gradually develop over time.
One extensively studied oncology example in patients revealed that more than 30
to 50% of cancer patients worldwide experience psychopathological problems each
year, making these issues among the most common globally. Although the
morbidity of psychopathological complications in patients is very high, they
are often inadvertently overlooked. In most of these cases, even if a
psychiatrist makes a correct diagnosis, treatment is often not strictly adhered
to by the patient or is neglected altogether. Internal stress is a constant
stimulus that also results in a constant increase in cortisol levels. Normally,
cortisol, one of the stress hormones, is produced in the adrenal glands. The
production of this hormone is controlled by the hypothalamus, and its
production is mainly associated with stress or low blood glucocorticoid levels.
Cortisol also acts as a neurotransmitter in the brain. Since 1999, brain
structures have been studied to highlight whether there are changes in brain
structures that may have been attributed to psychological distress caused by
chronic stress, which, if prolonged over time, can lead to the development of
depression. Several scientists surmise that recent vigorous brain research,
will aid psychiatry to recognize the effect of corticosteroids on brain
function and the morpho-structural and functional changes that occur thereafter
in the brain in relation to the psychopathological changes that occur.
This article explores the linkage between
psychological distress, high cortisol levels, and all the brain changes that
ensue. An extensive literature analysis has recently been conducted using the
PubMed database. To explore this, we analysed all article types using the
PubMed database, mainly focusing on all data from publications covering the
years from 2005 to 2023. The following "MeSH" terms were used in the
first PubMed search: chronic stress, cortisol, and neuroplasticity. A second
analysis has also been performed by cross-referencing the literature of
relevant articles identified in the first search.
Mental and physical health is surely affected by
stress, which, if prolonged, generates biochemical and physiological responses
in the body. Stress activates the adrenal glands, producing cortisol, a stress
hormone. Under normal stress conditions, cortisol decreases inflammation in the
body, but during chronic stress, the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis
is activated, resulting in excessive cortisol’s release and increased
inflammation [1]. Elevated cortisol levels activate immune cells, which are
highly sensitive to increases in cortisol or glucocorticoids. Glucocorticoids
regulate immune cells by binding to specific receptors. Normally, when
glucocorticoids bind to their receptors (GR), they activate and move to the
nucleus, resulting in repression of inflammatory signaling pathways, including
inhibition of NF-?B, a transcription factor crucial for activating pro-inflammatory
cytokines [2]. The mechanism of cortisol activation during acute stress
determines a greater increase in GR activation, which is more sensitive during
elevated cortisol levels. The duration of the interaction between cortisol and
GR is generally estimated to be in the neighbourhood of some hours after a
single cortisol peak. Eventually, this would result in better control of the
body’s inflammation. In the case of chronic stress, when elevated cortisol
levels remain constant over a long period of time, receptor resistance to
glucocorticoid stimuli occurs. This resistance state results in a lower number
of GRs and a noticeable decrease in receptor affinity, leading to increased
inflammation. The inflammation process begins when NF-?B and its genes are
activated. Activated NF-?B will code for pro-inflammatory mediators, initiating
the inflammation cascade [2,3]. A meta-analysis study showed the difference in
inflammation between patients with depression and the control group without
depression. In this scientific study, patients with depression showed increased
serum levels of pro-inflammatory cytokines (IL-1?, IL-2, IL-6, IL-12, TNF-?),
while very low levels of anti-inflammatory cytokines (IL-4, IL-10, transforming
growth factor [TGF]-?1) were revealed [4].
Prolonged elevations of glucocorticoids (GC), such as
cortisol, generate: inhibition of neurogenesis in the brain, excitotoxicity,
brain atrophy in the hippocampus, specifically in the branching points of the
dendrites of CA1 and CA3 regions. High levels of GC could also cause
cytoarchitectural damage in the brain [5]. Prolonged elevated cortisol levels
for many hours primarily trigger neurodegenerative processes in the hippocampus
and prefrontal cortex [6]. In the hippocampus, there is an increase in neuronal
death by apoptosis, resulting in a loss of neurons and a decrease in
hippocampal volume. This has been observed in rodents, monkeys, humans, and
presumably in most other mammals [7] as a direct reaction to perceived
environmental stress. The hippocampus, affected by neuronal loss, reduces its
capacity for negative feedback control over cortisol release by the adrenal
glands, resulting in chronic hypercortisolemia and the so-called cortisol
intoxication. In this case, the hippocampus loses its function vis-à-vis
stopping cortisol release, and hence its levels remain elevated, causing a
lasting systemic self-catabolic potentiation known as the "stress
cascade" [5,3]. Acute and chronic stress has proven to have a direct
impact on the hippocampus and the medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) [8]. Studies
have shown that the mPFC can decrease the stress response [9]. This has been
evidenced in the amygdala, which receives extensive inhibitory collaterals from
the prefrontal cortex [10]. Studies on the effects of acute stress have also
shown negative effects on cognitive flexibility, attention regulation, and
working memory [11]. For example, watching emotionally disturbing movies has
been associated with significantly reduced prefrontal cortex activation. Neuroimaging
studies have shown that acute stress negatively affects the activation of the
brain area related to working memory in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex
[12]. On the other hand, chronic stress leads to dendritic retraction and
de-branching in many areas of the mPFC, as observed in rodent and primate
models [13-15].
Laboratory rats’ studies subjected to high chronic
stress levels have shown a significant volumetric reduction in the mPFC. mPFC's
interferes with the ability to suppress the stress response [16]. These volume
reductions in the mPFC are limited to the upper layers, where most hippocampal
projections end [17]. Both hippocampus and mPFC demostrate dendritic damage
associated with chronic stress. Another consequence of chronic stress is a significant
decrease in synapse density in various regions of the prefrontal cortex,
including the mPFC and the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex. In contrast, there
had been no observed dendritic material loss in the infralimbic mPFC neurons
projecting to the amygdala in laboratory where rats were subjected to chronic
stress [18]. This showed that amygdala neural circuits remain intact/unchanged.
Chronic stress increases oxidative stress damage in the body while also
reducing the body's antioxidant defense [19,20]. Oxidative stress occurs when
oxygen free radicals exceed the capacity of antioxidants to neutralize them
[20]. Chronic stress reduces mitochondrial cells function and decreases
glutathione (GSH) levels. A study identified GSH level reduction in patients as
an indicator of oxidative stress level. Higher oxidative stress correlates with
lower GSH levels [21]. Oxidative stress damage has also been identified in the
brains of sleep-deprived individuals [22,23]. Hypercortisolemia reduces
brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) expression, thus contributing to
induced neuronal damage. Hypercortisolemia causes various inauspicious effects,
including morphological and structural changes in the brain [2,3]. Chronic
stress is associated with "neuroinflammation" (i.e., activated
microglia and astrocytes) and elevated levels of circulating damage-associated
molecular patterns (DAMPs), which are endogenous molecules produced by the body
under chronic stress. These molecules, similar to oxidative damage, can cause cell’s
necrosis [2].
In acute stress cases, elevated dopamine levels cause hyperstimulation of dopamine D1 [24,25] receptors, and a decrease in sustained activity and proper coordination of prefrontal cortex neurons. This effect has been observed in humans and other mammals [26]. The same also applies to chronic stress cases. In acute stress cases, while elevated glucocorticoid levels increase short-term dopaminergic transmission in the mesocortical system, prolonged increases in glucocorticoids, as seen in chronic stress, decrease dopaminergic transmission, thus causing similar decreases in sustained activity and proper coordination of prefrontal cortex neurons [16]. This also leads to deterioration and decline in the working memory. This pattern is similar to what is observed in hippocampus-dependent memory. In the hippocampus, there is also an "inverted-U" relationship with stress, where low to moderate stress can improve memory, but chronic stress with elevated glucocorticoid levels can cause a decline in the memory’s efficiency. The "inverted-U" details how stress affects working memory: it improves it up to a certain point under low to moderate stress levels, but excessive stress causes significant memory degeneration [25]. The intestine, often referred to as the "second brain," plays a critical role in the connection between stress, neuropsychiatric disorders, and gut health. Stress and these disorders are linked to changes in gut microbiota, which can lead to microbial translocation from the gut into the bloodstream, a phenomenon known as "leaky gut." This process increases the presence of pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs), which act as inflammatory triggers. Both PAMPs and damage-associated molecular patterns (DAMPs) can activate signalling pathways through Toll-like receptors (TLRs), Nod-like receptor 3 (NLRP3), and immune cells like Caspase-1, ultimately boosting pro-inflammatory cytokine production [2]. These cytokines can then reach the brain, where they activate microglia and astrocytes, contributing to neuroinflammation and affecting brain function (Chronic stress, cortical plasticity, and neuroecology).
It is now known that chronic stress definitely and
categorically generates continuously high cortisol levels. This has been proven to induce
morpho-structural changes in certain parts of the brain’s region. The
hippocampus, amygdala, and prefrontal cortex are particularly sensitive to
these changes thus causing multitude of problems with planning, organizing,
memory functioning, recalling abilities, and also in maintaining coherence.
Moreover, patients who are suffering from stress have also been found to have
troubles finding the right words while thinking, as well as reading new
materials, or even with proper orientation.
Patients in such cases describe such brain changes as
someone having who have had a stuffed head full of cotton or a “brain fog”,
which can evidently lead to unwarranted emotional problems. As chronic stress
increases, the limbic system starts impeding the flow of information to the
cerebral neocortex causing emotional disturbances that ultimately causes acute
distress. At this point, the so-called homeostasis between the brainstem, the
limbic system and the cerebral cortex is completely lost. Chronic cortisol
elevation effects are also manifested through a series of biochemical and
physiological responses involving multiple systems of the human body. In this
article, we want to theoretically analyse the mechanism through which chronic
cortisol secretion could induce a cycle of atypical functions that we could
name a vicious cycle (Figure 1). This vicious cycle could theoretically consist
of four phases (Figure 1).
1st
Phase
The first phase of this vicious cycle starts with an overwhelmingly incessant sense of stress, anxiety, or even long-term depression lasting for as long as six months or sometimes even more [26]. During this prolonged stress period, the body’s hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis is in constant agitation, resulting in relentless secretion of cortisol, a condition known as hypercortisolemia. This unabated elevation of cortisol sets the stage for a cascade of health issues, illustrating the body's struggle to cope with continuous stress and its profound repercussions.
Figure 1: Stress, anxiety and depression if continues uninterrupted will establish a vicious cycle.
2nd
Phase
The second phase of this vicious cycle, shifts focus
to the body’s predisposition for inflammation control and the overall body
health [1]. Hypercortisolemia, which is marked by elevated cortisol levels,
triggers immune cells which are highly sensitive to glucocorticoids. Under
normal conditions, glucocorticoids bind to their specific receptors (GR) and
suppress inflammatory signalling pathways by inhibiting the transcription
factor NF-?B, which is crucial for activating proinflammatory cytokines [2].
This suppression is the way how glucocorticoids exert their therapeutic
effects, by reducing inflammatory mediators and regulating the immune system’s
response [3]. Prolonged hypercortisolemia also leads to a self-resistance
development in glucocorticoid receptors, thus reducing both their numbers and
their affinity. This resistance causes a continuous activation of NF-?B, thus
triggering a cascade of chronic inflammation [3,4]. Essentially, sustained
stress inhibits the body's immune function, leading, among other things, to
persistent inflammation and health deterioration.
3rd Phase
The third phase of this cycle (Figure 1), starts to
exhibit both anatomical and pathological effects which become even more evident
(Figure 2). At this stage, diagnosing chronic stress and implementing a
therapeutic regimen for secondary prevention becomes crucially necessary. One
significant pathological condition observed at this phase is the alteration of
the intestinal microbiota. Elevated cortisol levels under chronic stress can
also lead to dysbiosis, an imbalance in the gut microbiota, aggravating further
the vicious cycle of stress and expediting health deterioration. This imbalance
can increase intestinal permeability, a phenomenon known as "leaky
gut". Greater intestinal permeability allows for the translocation of
microbes and their agents (pathogen-associated molecular patterns, PAMPs) into
the bloodstream. These PAMPs can induce an inflammatory response by activating
Toll-like receptors (TLRs) and Nod-like receptor 3 (NLRP3) in the immune cells,
thereby increasing the production of pro-inflammatory cytokines. These
pro-inflammatory cytokines can even reach the brain and activate microglia and
astrocytes, which in turn could lead to the exacerbation of neuro-inflammation which
causes neuronal damage, a subject that will be discussed underneath [3,27].
This process permeates the vicious cycle of chronic stress, inflammation, and
neuronal damage, thus causing inauspicious effects on the physical and mental
health of the individual. Hypercortisolemia can also affect the Cancer tumour
microenvironment; cortisol and other stress hormones can modify the tumor’s
immune function environment, thus promoting cancer growth or even metastasis.
Chronic stress has also been discerned to increase the expression of genes
associated with infiltration and metastasis into the cancer cells, as well as
weakening the immune response against cancer [28]. These effects can largely be
mitigated through the activation of signalling pathways such as the epidermal
growth factor (EGF) and mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) pathways [29].
Moreover, elevated cortisol levels were found to cause alterations in cytokine
signalling in the tumour microenvironment. Studies have shown that stress can
elevate the production of pro-inflammatory cytokines such as IL-6 and TNF-? in
the tumour environment, which could in turn promote angiogenesis and tumour
growth [30]. These effects may be particularly important in breast cancer
cases, where it has been noted that chronic stress could increase instances of
metastasis by modifying the blood-brain barrier and promoting cancer cell
infiltration [31]. Furthermore, oncological studies in patients have found that
chronic stress can modify the tumor microenvironment through immunosuppression
and inflammation, thus affecting inauspiciously cancer progression [32]. The
relationship between stress and cancer not only involves the immune changes but
also alterations in cell signalling and gene expression that can affect the proliferation
and metastasis of cancer cells [33,34]. Chronic stress and elevated cortisol
levels are also implicated in numerous pathologies, each of which significantly
affecting the human health, and more importantly, the quality of live, as
illustrated in (Figure 2).
Figure 2: Pathological Effect of the Third Phase of the Vicious Cycle.
Cardiovascular
Disease: Chronic stress has been linked to a
higher risk of cardiovascular disease. Research from the European Journal of
Preventive Cardiology (2017) and the American Heart Association [35] have shown
that elevated cortisol can lead to higher blood pressure and arterial plaque
build-up.
Type
2 Diabetes: A 2018 longitudinal study published
in Diabetes Care, found a significant link between perceived stress and the
risk of type 2 diabetes in middle-aged adults [36].
Gastrointestinal
Disorders: Chronic stress have also been found to
exacerbate gastrointestinal issues like irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) and
inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), as noted by
Ge [37].
Obesity:
Elevated cortisol from chronic stress could also lead to unwarranted abdominal
fat accumulation, a key risk factor for obesity and related metabolic disorders
[19]. Stress can also disrupt cognitive functions such as self-regulation and
promote unhealthy behaviors such as overeating, particularly in consumed foods
that have high-calories, fatty, and sugary ingredients [38].
Sleep
Disorders: Stress have also been shown to negatively
impact sleep quality patterns. Research by Kalmbach [39] discusses the concept
of sleep pathogenic reactivity, which relates to an individual's susceptibility
to stress-related sleep disorders.
Mental
Health Issues: Chronic stress has been found to
cause severe mental disorder namely: depression, anxiety, PTSD, and bipolar
disease, as documented in the Journal of Affective Disorders [40].
Immune
Dysfunction: Everyday stress, on the other hand
can significantly limit the immune function and negatively impact individual’s
overall health. Seiler [41] explored this unique relationship, while Castellani
[42] highlighted the close physical and functional communication between the
brain and the immune system, revealing new pathways for brain-immune
interactions.
Autoimmune
Diseases: Chronic stress, have also been found to
trigger or worsen autoimmune diseases like rheumatoid arthritis and lupus [43]
study of a Swedish cohort revealed a significant association between
stress-related disorders and increased risk of autoimmune diseases, emphasizing
the need for effective stress management treatment and hence prevention.
The above findings have come to underscore the
profound impact of chronic stress on multiple aspects of health. It also came
to highlight the immediate need for effective stress management strategies to
either mitigate these risks, or even eradicate them altogether. This scientific
evidence supports the link between chronic stress and a variety of health
conditions, thus providing a more comprehensive understanding of the various
effects of stress on the body and mind through the different phases of this
vicious and incessant “vicious cycle”.
4th
Phase
The fourth phase of the vicious cycle (Figure 1) is
marked by profound structural and functional changes in the brain, including
the inhibition of neurogenesis, excitotoxicity, and brain atrophy. Notably, the
hippocampus, a critical region for memory and learning, experiences significant
gradual neuronal loss and reduced volume [5,3]. Excitotoxicity refers to
cellular damage caused by the overstimulation of glutamate receptors in the
nerve cells. While glutamate is essential for neurotransmission, excessive
amounts, though, could unnecessarily lead to neuronal death. This phenomenon is
manifested in various neurodegenerative conditions following brain injuries,
which contribute to a significant disease progression. In the context of
chronic hypercortisolemia, the overstimulation of glutamate receptors in the
hippocampus is particularly detrimental. The hippocampus is highly sensitive to
cortisol due to its dense concentration of glucocorticoid receptors. Elevated
cortisol levels have shown to trigger excessive glutamate release, leading to
excitotoxicity and neuronal death, which adversely impacts memory and learning
[5]. Furthermore, chronic stress and elevated cortisol disrupt synaptic
plasticity by altering gene expression and inhibiting the formation of new
neuronal connections. This impairment of neuroplasticity in the hippocampus not
only hampers memory and learning abilities, but also exacerbates the structural
damage, thus creating a feedback loop that leads to cognitive decline [3].
These changes have found to have significant implications on cognitive
function, as neuroplasticity is essential for learning, memory, and
adaptability to new environments. Hence, impaired neuroplasticity due to
excitotoxicity and hypercortisolemia may lead to cognitive deficits and could
hinder the brain's ability to adapt and respond to environmental challenges,
underscoring the need for speedy proactive stress management strategies. The
cytoarchitectural changes compromise hippocampus's ability of regulating
cortisol release, perpetuating high cortisol levels and worsening
neurodegeneration [5]. Besides the hippocampus, the medial prefrontal cortex
(mPFC) have also been found to be vulnerable to elevated cortisol. Studies on
rodents and primates have shown that hypercortisolemia causes dendritic
retraction and disorganization in the mPFC, thus impairing stress response
suppression and leading to cognitive dysfunction [11-15]. This damage affects
working memory, attention focusing, in addition to other cognitive functions
[16].
Chronic stress, have also been found to reduce
synaptic density in the prefrontal cortex. Experiments on rats revealed a
significant decrease in the volume of mPFC, especially in areas where
hippocampal projections ends [17]. This synaptic density reduction impacts
cognitive flexibility and attention [18]. Moreover, hypercortisolemia lowers
brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) expression, thus exacerbating neuronal
damage and cognitive impairment [44,45]. Acute and chronic stress affects the
brain in various ways. For instance, short-term stress can enhance working
memory and cognitive functions by increasing dopaminergic transmission, whereas
prolonged glucocorticoid levels decrease this transmission, thus impairing
sustained activity and coordination in the prefrontal cortex [16,25]. Increased
microglial and astrocyte activation, along with elevated damage-associated
molecular patterns (DAMPs), could also lead, among other things, to cell
necrosis [2]. Neuroinflammation, triggered by immune cell activation and
oxidative stress, releases proinflammatory cytokines, causing significant
neuronal damage [46]. Gut microbiota changes could also impact neurotransmitter
and neuroactive metabolite production. These metabolites influence
neuroinflammation, the blood-brain barrier, and neuronal signaling,
exacerbating in their way chronic stress effects on the brain [47].These
metabolites can affect neuroinflammation, the blood-brain barrier and neuronal
signalling, inauspiciously affecting the brain’s chronic stress. Understanding
these mechanisms underscores the critical impact of chronic stress on brain’s
health and the urgent need for early intervention which is paramount for stress
management to halt long-term neurological damage.
Managing hypercortisolemia with proper medical
intervention have also been found to halt this harmful cycle (Figure 1). The
interplay between stress, inflammation, and gut microbiota offers promising
conduits for mitigating, or even eradicating, chronic stress. For instance,
probiotics, prebiotics, and specific forms of diets could help restore
microbial balance and reduce inflammation [27]. Dietary strategies like the
Mediterranean diet, which is rich in fiber, antioxidants, and omega-3 fatty
acids, have shown to have significant benefits for mental health and
inflammation reduction [48]. Nutritional supplements like omega-3 fatty acids,
antioxidants, B vitamins, zinc, and magnesium aid neurotransmitter signalling
and help protect mitochondrial function. Additionally, regular physical activity
such as yoga and Mindfulness could enhance life’s quality by improving sleep
patterns and inhibiting elevated cortisol levels. Research done have indicated
that previously sedentary older adults who engaged in daily walking for six
months to up to a year have exhibited increased hippocampal size, most likely
due to enhanced neurogenesis in the dentate gyrus affected by rigirous exercise
and enriched environments [49]. Psychodiagnostic assessment and psychotherapy
are hence crucial for patients who suffer from chronic stress who are called
upon to reduce cortisol levels [50,51]. Finally, medications such as serotonin
and norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors, glucocorticoid modulators, and CRH
antagonists may also help reduce cortisol levels.
Various scientific reviews have summarized and
integrated materials relating to the relationships between physiological and
psychosocial stress, the stress hormone cortisol, regulated by the HPA axis,
and the morpho-structural changes that stress produces in the brain. Chronic
psychological stress has been shown to lead to increased cortisol levels in the
body, causing
morphological, structural, and functional alterations
at the cerebral level. Hypercortisolemia can cause changes in the brain,
leading to loss of neuroplasticity and episodic memory, thus forming the ideal
conditions for the development of neurodegenerative diseases and cancer. We
conclude that the implementation of medical intervention measures is crucial
for halting this rather treatable vicious cycle (Figure 1). Chronic stress has
shown to have profound and multifaceted effects on human health, impacting not
only the immune response and inflammation, but also the structure and function
of the brain. Understanding these mechanisms is fundamental for developing
effective interventions that helps in the mitigation, or even probably
eradication, of the adverse effects of chronic stress. Strategies that regulate
the stress response, improve psychological resilience, and restore microbial
balance have proven to be highly effective in addressing the adverse
consequences of chronic stress and hence help improving the overall human’s
health. Additional studies on the therapeutic effect of these medical
interventions in patients with chronic stress could empirically confirm our
vicious cycle hypothesis (Figure 1). Applying these interventions to patients
with chronic stress could comprehensively and multidimensionally improve their
health, leading to a significant enhancement in their quality of life. We suggest
that future research should focus on randomized scientific studies and brain
autopsies to empirically examine the medical consequences of chronic
hypercortisolemia. Additionally, exploring the impact of integrated approaches
such as the Mediterranean diet, regular physical activity, yoga, and specific
nutritional supplements could provide a solid foundation for new therapeutic
strategies. Stress is a modifiable risk factor, and growing evidence suggests
that effective managing of stress levels have yielded significant benefits for
human’s psychological and physical health. In summary, combating the
devastating effects of chronic stress requires deep understanding of its
mechanisms and a holistic treatment approach, combining medical interventions,
psychological therapies, and lifestyle changes to restore balance and overall
health in affected individuals.