Article Type : Research Article
Authors : Helvaci MR, Helvaci E, Helvaci E, Aydin Y, Aydin LY, Sevinc A, Camci C, Abyad A and Pocock L
Keywords : Sickle cell diseases; Excess fat tissue; Obesity; Acarbose; Metformin; Endothelial inflammation; Atherosclerosis
Background:
Obesity may be an irreversible atherosclerotic endpoint in human body.
Methods:
Sickle cell diseases (SCD) patients were studied.
Results:
We studied 222 males and 212 females (30.8 vs 30.3 years of age, p>0.05,
respectively). Smoking (23.8% vs 6.1%, p<0.001), alcohol (4.9% vs 0.4%,
p<0.001), transfused red blood cells (RBC) in their lives (48.1 vs 28.5
units, p=0.000), disseminated teeth losses (5.4% vs 1.4%, p<0.001), ileus
(7.2% vs 1.4%, p<0.001), stroke (12.1% vs 7.5%, p<0.05), chronic renal
disease (CRD) (9.9% vs 6.1%, p<0.05), cirrhosis (8.1% vs 1.8%, p<0.001),
chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (25.2% vs 7.0%, p<0.001), coronary
heart disease (18.0% vs 13.2%, p<0.05), leg ulcers (19.8% vs 7.0%,
p<0.001), and digital clubbing (14.8% vs 6.6%, p<0.001) were all higher
in males, significantly.
Conclusion:
As an accelerated atherosclerotic process, hardened RBC-induced capillary
endothelial damage terminates with end-organ insufficiencies in early decades
of life in SCD. Although atherosclerotic endpoints are so common, we detected
no case of diabetes mellitus (DM) probably due to lower excess fat tissue. As
the most common cause of CRD, DM may be a relative insufficiency of pancreas
against the excess fat tissue. Increased blood and insulin requirements of
excess fat in contrast to decreased blood supply of excess tissue and pancreas
both due to excess external pressure and internal narrowing of vasculature may
be important for DM. As the most common cause of DM, obesity may be an
irreversible atherosclerotic endpoint in human body. Acarbose and metformin are
oral, safe, cheap, and effective drugs to prevent obesity.
Chronic
endothelial damage initiated at birth may be the most common cause of aging and
death via the atherosclerotic endpoints in human being [1]. Much higher blood
pressures (BP) of the arterial system may be the strongest accelerating factor
by means of the repeated injuries on vascular endothelium. Probably, whole
afferent vasculature including capillaries are chiefly involved in the
catastrophic process. Therefore, venosclerosis is not a significant health
problem in medicine. Due to the chronic endothelial damage, inflammation, and
fibrosis, vascular walls thicken, their lumens narrow, and they lose their
elastic natures, which terminally reduce blood supply to the end-organs, and
increase systolic and decrease diastolic BP further. Some of the well-known
accelerating factors of the inflammatory process are physical inactivity,
emotional stress, animal-rich diet, smoking, alcohol, excess fat tissue,
chronic inflammation, prolonged infection, and cancers for the development of
atherosclerotic endpoints including obesity, hypertension (HT), diabetes
mellitus (DM), chronic renal disease (CRD), coronary heart disease (CHD),
cirrhosis, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), peripheric artery
disease (PAD), stroke, abdominal angina, osteoporosis, dementia, aging, and
death [2,3]. Although early withdrawal of the accelerating factors can delay
the atherosclerotic endpoints, the endothelial changes cannot be reversed,
completely due to fibrotic natures. The accelerating factor and atherosclerotic
endpoints have been researched under the titles of metabolic syndrome, aging
syndrome, and accelerated endothelial damage syndrome in the literature,
extensively [4-6]. Similarly, sickle cell diseases (SCD) are highly
catastrophic process on vascular endothelium initiating at birth and
terminating with an accelerated atherosclerosis-induced end-organ
insufficiencies even at childhood [7,8]. Hemoglobin S causes loss of elastic
and biconcave disc shaped structures of red blood cells (RBC). Loss of
elasticity instead of shape may be the main problem because the sickling is
rare in peripheric blood samples of cases with associated thalassemia minors
(TM), and survival is not affected in hereditary spherocytosis or
elliptocytosis. Loss of elasticity is present during whole lifespan, but
exaggerated with inflammation, infection, cancer, surgery, and emotional
stress. The hardened RBC-induced chronic endothelial damage, inflammation, and
fibrosis terminate with tissue hypoxia in whole body [9]. As a difference from
other causes of chronic endothelial damage, SCD keep vascular endothelium
particularly at the capillary level since the capillary system is the main
distributor of the hardened RBC into the body [10,11]. The hardened RBC-induced
chronic endothelial damage builds up an accelerated atherosclerosis in earlier
decades of life. Vascular narrowing and obstructions-induced tissue ischemia
and end-organ insufficiencies are the terminal consequences, so the mean life
expectancy is decreased 30 years or more in the SCD because we have patients
with the age of 96 years without the SCD but just with the age of 59 years with
the SCD [8].
The
study was performed in the Medical Faculty of the Mustafa Kemal University
between March 2007 and June 2016. All cases with the SCD were included. SCD are
diagnosed with the hemoglobin electrophoresis performed via high performance
liquid chromatography (HPLC). Smoking, alcohol, acute painful crises per year,
transfused units of RBC in their lifespans, leg ulcers, stroke, surgeries, deep
venous thrombosis (DVT), epilepsy, and priapism were researched in all
patients. Cases with a history of one pack-year were accepted as smokers, and
one drink-year were accepted as drinkers. A physical examination was performed
by the Same Internist, and patients with disseminated teeth losses (<20
teeth present) were detected. Patients with acute painful crisis or any other
inflammatory or infectious process were treated at first, and the laboratory
tests and clinical measurements were performed on the silent phase. Checkup
procedures including serum iron, iron binding capacity, ferritin, creatinine,
liver function tests, markers of hepatitis viruses A, B, and C, a
posterior-anterior chest x-ray film, an electrocardiogram, a Doppler
echocardiogram both to evaluate cardiac walls and valves and to measure
systolic BP of pulmonary artery, an abdominal ultrasonography, a venous Doppler
ultrasonography of the lower limbs, a computed tomography (CT) of brain, and
magnetic resonance imaging’s (MRI) of brain and hips were performed. Other
bones for avascular necrosis were scanned according to the patients’
complaints. Avascular necrosis of bones is diagnosed via MRI [12]. Associated
TM were detected with serum iron, iron binding capacity, ferritin, and
hemoglobin electrophoresis performed via HPLC since SCD with associated TM come
with milder clinics than the sickle cell anemia (SCA) (Hb SS) alone [13].
Systolic BP of the pulmonary artery of 40 mmHg or greater are accepted as
pulmonary hypertension [14]. Cirrhosis is diagnosed with full physical
examination, laboratory parameters, and ultrasonographic evaluation of the
liver. The criterion for diagnosis of COPD is a post-bronchodilator forced
expiratory volume in one second/forced vital capacity of lower than 70% [15].
Acute chest syndrome (ACS) is diagnosed clinically with the presence of new
infiltrates on chest x-ray film, fever, cough, sputum, dyspnea, and hypoxia
[16]. An x-ray film of abdomen in upright position was taken just in patients
with abdominal distention or discomfort, vomiting, obstipation, or lack of
bowel movement, and ileus is diagnosed with gaseous distention of isolated
segments of bowel, vomiting, obstipation, cramps, and with the absence of
peristaltic activity. CRD is diagnosed with a permanently elevated serum
creatinine level of 1.3 mg/dL or higher in males and 1.2 mg/dL or higher in
females. Digital clubbing is diagnosed with the ratio of distal phalangeal
diameter to interphalangeal diameter of higher than 1.0, and with the presence
of Schamroth’s sign [17,18]. An exercise electrocardiogram is taken in case of
an abnormal electrocardiogram and/or angina pectoris. Coronary angiography is
performed in case of a positive exercise electrocardiogram. As a result, CHD
was diagnosed either angiographically or with the Doppler echocardiographic
findings as movement disorders in the heart walls. Rheumatic heart disease is
diagnosed with the echocardiographic findings, too. Stroke is diagnosed by the
CT and/or MRI of the brain. Sickle cell retinopathy is diagnosed with
ophthalmologic examination in case of visual complaints. Mann-Whitney U test,
Independent-Samples t test, and comparison of proportions were used as the
methods of statistical analyses.
We
included 222 males and 212 females with similar mean ages (30.8 vs 30.3 years,
p>0.05, respectively) into the study, and there was no patient above the age
of 59 years. Associated TM were detected with similar prevalences in both
genders (72.5% vs 67.9%, p>0.05, respectively). Smoking (23.8% vs 6.1%) and
alcohol (4.9% vs 0.4%) were both higher in males (p<0.001 for both) (Table
1). Transfused units of RBC in their lives (48.1 vs 28.5, p=0.000),
disseminated teeth losses (5.4% vs 1.4%, p<0.001), ileus (7.2% vs 1.4%,
p<0.001), CRD (9.9% vs 6.1%, p<0.05), cirrhosis (8.1% vs 1.8%,
p<0.001), COPD (25.2% vs 7.0%, p<0.001), CHD (18.0% vs 13.2%, p<0.05),
leg ulcers (19.8% vs 7.0%, p<0.001), digital clubbing (14.8% vs 6.6%,
p<0.001), and stroke (12.1% vs 7.5%, p<0.05) were all higher in males,
significantly. Although the mean age of mortality (30.2 vs 33.3 years) was
lower in males, the difference was nonsignificant, probably due to the small
sample sizes (Table 2). On the other hand, the mean ages of the atherosclerotic
endpoints were shown in (Table 3).
Excess
fat tissue may be the most common cause of vasculitis and aging, and obesity
may be an irreversible atherosclerotic endpoint in human body. Excess fat
tissue causes both excess external pressure and internal narrowing of
vasculature in addition to the already increased blood and insulin needs of the
excess tissue. DM may be an irreversible atherosclerotic consequence caused by
the excess fat tissue in whole body rather than the pancreas alone. Although
all kinds of atherosclerotic consequences are so common with the SCD, we have
detected no case of DM, probably due to the lower excess fat tissue in them
[10]. The body mass indexes (BMI) were 20.7 vs 24.9 kg/m2 in the SCD and
control groups, respectively with the mean age of 28.6 years (p= 0.000) [10].
The body heights were similar in both groups (166.1 vs 168.5 cm, respectively,
p>0.05) which may indicate that the height is determined, genetically [10].
Similarly, just 20% of elderly have DM, but 55% of patients with DM are obese.
So excess fat tissue may be riskier than aging, smoking, alcohol, or chronic
inflammatory or infectious processes for the development of DM. Excess fat
tissue leads to a chronic and low-grade inflammation on vascular endothelium,
and risk of death from all causes increases parallel to its severity [19]. The
low-grade chronic inflammation may also cause genetic changes on the
endothelial cells, and the systemic atherosclerotic process may even decrease
clearance of malignant cells by the natural killers [20]. The chronic inflammatory
process is characterized by lipid-induced injury, invasion of macrophages,
proliferation of smooth muscle cells, endothelial dysfunction, and increased
atherogenicity [21,22]. Excess fat tissue is considered as a strong factor for
controlling of C-reactive protein (CRP) since the excess tissue produces
biologically active leptin, tumor necrosis factor-alpha, plasminogen activator
inhibitor-1, and adiponectin-like cytokines [23,24]. On the other hand, excess
fat tissue will also aggravate myocardial hypertrophy and decrease cardiac
compliance. Fasting plasma glucose (FPG), triglycerides, and low-density
lipoproteins (LDL) increased and high-density lipoproteins (HDL) decreased
parallel to the severity of BMI [25]. Similarly, CHD and stroke increased parallel
to the severity of BMI [26]. Eventually, the risk of death from all causes
increased parallel to the severity of excess fat tissue in all age groups, and
people with underweight may even have lower biological ages and longer overall
survival [27]. Similarly, calorie restriction prolongs survival and retards
age-related chronic sicknesses [28]. So, the term of excess weight should be
replaced with the amount of excess fat tissue in human body since there are
nearly 19 kg of excess fat tissue even between the lower and upper borders of
normal weight in adults.
Smoking
may be the second most common cause of vasculitis all over the body. It causes
a systemic inflammation on vascular endothelium terminating with
atherosclerotic endpoints [29]. Its atherosclerotic effects are the most
obvious in the Buerger’s disease and COPD [30]. Buerger’s disease is an
obliterative vasculitis in the small and medium-sized arteries and veins, and
it has never been reported in the absence of smoking in the literature. Its
characteristic features are chemical toxicity, inflammation, fibrosis, and
narrowing and occlusions of arteries and veins. Claudication is the most
significant symptom with a severe pain in feet and hands caused by insufficient
blood supply during exercise. It may also radiate to central areas in advanced
cases. Numbness or tingling of the limbs is also a common symptom in them. Skin
ulcerations and gangrene of fingers or toes are the terminal endpoints. Similar
to the venous ulcers, diabetic ulcers, leg ulcers of the SCD, digital clubbing,
onychomycosis, and delayed wound and fracture healings of the lower
extremities, pooling of blood due to the gravity may be the main cause of
severity of Buerger's disease in the lower extremities. Several narrowing and
occlusions of the arm and legs are diagnostic in the angiogram. Skin biopsies
may be risky, because a poorly perfused area will not heal, completely.
Although most patients are heavy smokers, the limited smoking history of some
patients may support the hypothesis that Buerger's disease may be an autoimmune
reaction triggered by some constituents of tobacco. Although the only treatment
way is complete cessation of smoking, the already developed narrowing and
occlusions are irreversible. Due to the well-known role of inflammation,
anti-inflammatory dose of aspirin in addition to the low-dose warfarin may even
be life threatening by preventing microvascular infarctions. On the other hand,
FPG and HDL may be negative whereas triglycerides, LDL, erythrocyte
sedimentation rate, and CRP positive acute phase reactants (APR) in smokers
[31]. Similarly, smoking was associated with the lower BMI due to the systemic
inflammatory effects [32,33]. An increased heart rate was detected just after
smoking even at rest [34]. Nicotine supplied by patch after smoking cessation
decreased caloric intake in a dose-related manner [35]. Nicotine may lengthen
intermeal time, and decrease amount of meal eaten [36]. Smoking may be
associated with a post cessation weight gain, but the risk is the highest
during the first year, and decreases with the following years [37]. Although
the CHD was detected with similar prevalences in both genders, prevalences of
smoking and COPD were higher in males against the higher white coat
hypertension, BMI, LDL, triglycerides, HT, and DM in females [38]. The risk of
myocardial infarction is increased three-fold in men and six-fold in women with
smoking [39]. Chemical toxicity of smoking can affect all organ systems. For
instance, it is usually associated with irritable bowel syndrome (IBS), chronic
gastritis, hemorrhoids, urolithiasis, and depression with many possible
mechanisms [40]. First of all, smoking may also have some anxiolytic
properties. Secondly, smoking-induced vascular inflammation may disturb
epithelial absorption and excretion in the gastrointestinal (GI) and
genitourinary (GU) tracts [41]. Thirdly, diarrheal losses-induced urinary
changes may cause urolithiasis [42]. Fourthly, smoking-induced sympathetic
nervous system activation may cause motility problems in the GI and GU tracts
terminating with IBS and urolithiasis. Finally, immunosuppression secondary to
smoking may terminate with the GI and GU tract infections and urolithiasis
because some types of bacteria can provoke urinary supersaturation, and modify
the environment to form crystal deposits. Actually, 10% of urinary stones are
struvite stones which are built by magnesium ammonium phosphate produced by the
urease producing bacteria. As a result, urolithiasis was higher in the IBS
patients, significantly (17.9% vs 11.6%, p<0.01) [40].
CHD
is the other major cause of death in the human being together with the stroke.
The most common triggering cause is the disruption of an atherosclerotic plaque
in an epicardial coronary artery, which leads to a clotting cascade. The
plaques are the gradual and unstable collection of lipids, fibrous tissue, and
white blood cells (WBC), particularly the macrophages in arterial walls in
decades of life. Stretching and relaxation of arteries with each heart beat
increases mechanical shear stress on atheroma’s to rupture. After the
myocardial infarction, a collagen scar tissue takes its place which may also
cause life threatening arrhythmias because the scar tissue conducts electrical
impulses more slowly. The difference in conduction velocity between the injured
and uninjured tissues can trigger re-entry or a feedback loop that is believed
to be the cause of lethal arrhythmias. Ventricular fibrillation is the most
serious arrhythmia that is the leading cause of sudden cardiac death. It is an
extremely fast and chaotic heart rhythm. Ventricular tachycardia may also cause
sudden cardiac death that usually results in rapid heart rates preventing
effective cardiac pumping. Cardiac output and BP may fall to dangerous levels
which can lead to further coronary ischemia and extension of the infarct. This
scar tissue may even cause ventricular aneurysm and rupture. Aging, physical
inactivity, animal-rich diet, excess fat tissue, smoking, alcohol, emotional
stress, prolonged infection, chronic inflammation, and cancers are important in
atherosclerotic plaque formation. Moderate physical exercise is associated with
a 50% reduced incidence of CHD [43]. Probably, excess fat tissue may be the
most important cause of CHD because there are approximately 33 kg of excess fat
tissue between the lower borders of normal weight and obesity, and 66 kg
between the lower borders of normal weight and morbid obesity (BMI ? 40 kg/m2)
in adults. In other definition, there is a high percentage of adults with
heavier fat tissue masses than their lean body masses that brings a greater
stress on the heart, liver, kidneys, lungs, brain, and pancreas.
DM
is the most common cause of blindness, non-traumatic amputation, and
hemodialysis in adults. As the most common cause of CRD, DM may be an
irreversible atherosclerotic consequence affecting the pancreas, too. Increased
blood and insulin needs of the excess fat tissue in contrast to the decreased
blood supply of the excess tissue and pancreas both due to excess external
pressure and internal narrowing of the vasculature may be the underlying
mechanisms of DM. For instance, excess fat tissue in the liver and pancreas are
called as non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD) and non-alcoholic fatty
pancreas disease (NAFPD). They are usually accepted as components of the
metabolic syndrome. NAFLD progresses to steatohepatitis, cirrhosis, and
hepatocellular carcinoma. Blocking triglycerides secretion, subcellular lipid
sequestration, lipolysis deficiency, enhanced lipogenesis, gluconeogenesis
defects, or inhibition of fatty acid oxidation may be some of the development
mechanisms [44]. NAFLD may just be an atherosclerotic process, and strongly
associated with an accelerated atherosclerotic process not only in the liver
instead in whole body. For example, NAFLD is seen in one-third of cases with
hepatitis B virus-related chronic liver disease [45]. Similarly, higher fatty
liver ratios were observed in children with non-Hodgkin lymphomas [46]. The
liver density on contrast abdominopelvic CT of colorectal cancer patients was
low that is consistent with the NAFLD [47]. As one of the APR, serum
thrombopoietin levels increased in the NAFLD [48]. Although serum levels of
oxidizing agents including nitrate and advanced oxidation protein products
increased, serum nitrite did not adequately increase as an antioxidant agent in
the NAFLD [49]. As a result, NAFLD is associated with an impaired carotid
intima-media thickness (IMT) and flow-mediated dilation which are considered as
early markers of systemic atherosclerosis [50]. Carotid IMT was correlated with
the BMI (p<0.001), age (p= 0.001), and grade 2-3 NAFLD (p<0.001) [51]. Patients
with the NAFLD have more complex CHD, and carotid IMT and grade 2-3 NAFLD were
associated with the severity of CHD (p<0.001 for both) [51-53]. Similarly,
there were reductions in hepatic artery flow volume, portal vein flow volume,
and total flow volume in contrast to the increased NAFLD [54]. As the most
common pathology of pancreas in adults, there may be reductions in flow volume
of pancreatic arteries in the NAFPD, too [55]. NAFPD is usually associated with
the aging, increased BMI, and insulin resistance [56]. Replacement of more than
25% of pancreas by fat tissue is associated with the risks of systemic
atherosclerosis and DM [57]. Insulin is stored in vacuoles in beta cells of
islets of Langerhans in whole pancreas and released via exocytosis. Pancreatic
fat infiltration may lead to a reduced insulin secretion [58]. NAFPD may lead
to exocrine pancreatic insufficiency by fat droplet accumulation in pancreatic
acinar cells and consequent lip toxicity, destruction of acinar cells by both
inflammation and fatty replacement, and by negative paracrine effect of
adipocytes [59]. It is unsurprising that the NAFPD may even cause pancreatic
fibrosis and cancers. NAFPD causes a higher risk of DM [57], and newly
diagnosed patients with DM have higher pancreatic fat [60]. DM may actually be
a relative insufficiency of the pancreas against the excess fat tissue in whole
body. Age-related impairment of beta cells may actually be an atherosclerotic
endpoint since 20% of elderly have DM, and just 55% of patients with DM are
obese. Glucose tolerance progressively decreases by aging. It may be due to the
progressively decreased physical and mental activity-induced excess fat tissue
secreting adipokines. There is no term of malnutrition-related DM. DM can be
cured by gastric bypass surgery in 90% of morbid obese cases [61]. The effect
is not due to the weight loss instead decreased insulin requirement daily
because it usually occurs just after days of the surgery. This surgery reduced
death rate from all causes by 40% [61]. NAFPD is an independent risk factor for
CHD, too [62]. Similarly, NAFPD is associated with increased aortic IMT and
epicardial fat tissue [63]. As a result, NAFLD, cirrhosis, NAFPD, and DM may be
some irreversible atherosclerotic endpoints in human body [64].
Acute
painful crises are nearly pathognomonic for the SCD. Although some authors
reported that pain itself may not be life threatening directly, infection,
medical or surgical emergency, or emotional stresses are the most common
precipitating factors of the crises [65]. The increased basal metabolic rate
during such stresses aggravates the sickling and capillary endothelial damage,
inflammation, and edema terminating with tissue hypoxia and end-organ
insufficiencies in whole body. So, the risk of mortality is much higher during
such crises. Actually, each crisis may complicate with the following crises by
leaving sequalae’s on the capillary endothelial system all over the body. After
a period of time, the sequalae’s may terminate with end-organ failures and
sudden death with a silent painful crisis, clinically. Similarly, after a
20-year experience on such patients, the deaths seem sudden and unexpected
events in the SCD. Unfortunately, most of the deaths develop just after the
hospital admission, and majority of them are patients without hydroxyurea
therapy [66,67]. Rapid RBC supports are usually life-saving, although
preparation of RBC units usually takes a period of time. Beside that RBC
supports in emergencies become much more difficult in terminal cases due to the
repeated transfusions and interestingly aging-induced blood group mismatch.
Actually, transfusion of each unit complicates the following transfusions via
the blood subgroup mismatch. Due to the efficacy of hydroxyurea, RBC
transfusions should be preserved just for acute stress and emergencies [66-68].
According to our experiences, simple and repeated transfusions are superior to
exchange [69,70]. First of all, preparation of one or two units of RBC
suspensions in each time provides time to clinicians by preventing sudden
death. Secondly, transfusions of one or two units in each time decrease the
severity of pain, and relax the patients and their relatives since RBC
transfusions probably have the strongest analgesic effects [71]. Actually, the
decreased severity of pain by transfusions also indicates the decreased
severity of inflammation in whole body. Thirdly, transfusions of lesser units
will decrease transfusion-related complications including infections, iron
overload, and blood group mismatch. Fourthly, transfusions in the secondary
health centers prevent deaths developed during the transport to the tertiary
centers for the exchange. Terminally, cost of the simple transfusions on
insurance system is much lower than the exchange which needs trained staff and
additional devices. On the other hand, pain is the result of complex and poorly
understood interactions between RBC, WBC, platelets (PLT), and endothelial
cells, yet. Probably, leukocytosis contributes to the pathogenesis by releasing
cytotoxic enzymes. The adverse effects of WBC on vascular endothelium are of
particular interest for atherosclerotic endpoints. For example, leukocytosis
even in the absence of any infection was an independent predictor of the
severity of the SCD [72], and it was associated with the risk of stroke [73].
Disseminated tissue hypoxia, releasing of inflammatory mediators, bone
infarctions, and activation of afferent nerves may take role in the
pathophysiology of the intolerable pain. Due to the severity of pain, narcotic
analgesics are usually required [74], but simple transfusions are effective
both to relieve pain and to prevent sudden deaths which may develop due to the
end-organ failures on atherosclerotic background of the SCD.
Hydroxyurea
is the life-saving drug for the SCD. It interferes with the cell division by
blocking the formation of deoxyribonucleotides via the inhibition of
ribonucleotide reductase. The deoxyribonucleotides are the building blocks of
DNA. Hydroxyurea mainly affects hyperproliferating cells. Although the action
way of hydroxyurea is thought to be the increase in gamma-globin synthesis for
fetal hemoglobin (Hb F), its main action may be the suppression of leukocytosis
and thrombocytosis by blocking the DNA synthesis [75,76]. Due to the same
action way, hydroxyurea is also used in moderate and severe psoriasis to
suppress hyperproliferating skin cells. As in the viral hepatitis cases,
although presence of a continuous damage of sickle cells on the capillary
endothelium, the severity of catastrophic process is probably exaggerated by
the patients’ own WBC and PLT. So, suppression of proliferation of them can
limit the endothelial damage-induced edema, ischemia, and infarctions [77].
Similarly, Hb F levels in hydroxyurea users did not differ from their
pretreatment levels [78]. The Multicenter Study of Hydroxyurea (MSH) studied
299 severely affected adults with the SCA, and compared the results of patients
treated with hydroxyurea or placebo [79]. The study particularly researched
effects of hydroxyurea on painful crises, ACS, and need of RBC transfusion. The
outcomes were so overwhelming in the favor of hydroxyurea group that the study
was terminated after 22 months, and hydroxyurea was initiated for all patients.
The MSH also demonstrated that patients treated with hydroxyurea had a 44%
decrease in hospitalizations [79]. In multivariable analyses, there was a
strong and independent association of lower neutrophil counts with the lower
crisis rates [79]. But this study was performed just in severe SCA cases alone,
and the rate of painful crises was decreased from 4.5 to 2.5, annually [79].
Whereas we used all subtypes of the SCD with all clinical severity, and the
rate of painful crises was decreased from 10.3 to 1.7, annually (p<0.000)
with an additional decreased severity of them (7.8/10 vs 2.2/10, p<0.000)
[66]. Similarly, adults using hydroxyurea for frequent painful crises appear to
have reduced mortality rate after a 9-year follow-up period [80]. Although the
genetic severity remains as the main factor to determine prognosis, hydroxyurea
may decrease severity of disease and prolong survival [80]. The complications
start to be seen even after birth. For example, infants with lower hemoglobin
levels were more likely to have higher incidences of ACS, painful crises, and
lower neuropsychological scores, and hydroxyurea reduced the incidences of all
[81]. If started early, hydroxyurea may protect splenic function, improve
growth, and delay atherosclerotic endpoints. But due to the risks of
infections, iron overload, and development of all-antibodies causing subsequent
transfusions much more difficult, RBC transfusions should be preserved for
acute stress and emergencies as the most effective weapon in our hands.
Aspirin
is a member of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAID). Although aspirin
has similar anti-inflammatory effects with the other NSAID, it also suppresses
the normal functions of PLT, irreversibly. Aspirin acts as an acetylating agent
where an acetyl group is covalently attached to a serine residue in the active
site of the cyclooxygenase (COX) enzyme. Aspirin inactivates the COX enzyme,
irreversibly, which is required for the synthesis of prostaglandins (PG) and
thromboxanes (TX). PG are the locally produced hormones with some diverse
effects, including the transmission of pain into the brain and modulation of
the hypothalamic thermostat and inflammation. TX are responsible for the
aggregation of PLT to form blood clots. Low-dose aspirin irreversibly blocks
the formation of TXA2 in the PLT, producing an inhibitory effect on the PLT
aggregation during whole lifespan of the affected PLT (8-9 days). Since PLT do
not have nucleus and DNA, they are unable to synthesize new COX enzyme anymore.
But aspirin has no effect on the blood viscosity. The antithrombotic property
is useful to reduce the risks of myocardial infarction, transient ischemic
attack, and stroke [82]. Low-dose of aspirin is effective to prevent the second
myocardial infarction, too [83]. Aspirin may also be effective in prevention of
colorectal cancers [84]. On the other hand, aspirin has some side effects
including gastric ulcers, gastric bleeding, worsening of asthma, and Reye
syndrome in childhood and adolescence. Due to the risk of Reye syndrome, the US
Food and Drug Administration recommends that aspirin should not be prescribed
for febrile patients under the age of 12 years [85], and it was only
recommended for Kawasaki disease [86]. Reye syndrome is a rapidly worsening
brain disease [86]. The first detailed description of Reye syndrome was in 1963
by an Australian pathologist, Douglas Reye [87]. The syndrome mostly affects
children, but it can only affect fewer than one in a million children, annually
[87]. Symptoms of Reye syndrome may include personality changes, confusion,
seizures, and loss of consciousness [86]. Although the liver toxicity and
enlargement typically occurs in most cases, jaundice is usually not seen [86].
Although the death occurs in 20-40% of affected cases, about one third of
survivors get a significant degree of brain damage [86]. It usually starts just
after recovery from a viral infection, such as influenza or chicken pox. About
90% of children are associated with an aspirin use [87,88]. Inborn errors of
metabolism are also the other risk factors, and the genetic testing for inborn
errors of metabolism became available in developed countries in the 1980s [86].
When aspirin was withdrawn for children in the US and UK, a decrease of more
than 90% in rates of Reye syndrome was seen in the 1980s [87]. Due to the much
lower risk of Reye syndrome but much higher risk of death, aspirin must be
added into the acute and chronic phase treatments with an anti-inflammatory
dose even in childhood in the SCD [89].
Warfarin
is an anticoagulant, and it has no effect on blood viscosity, too. It is the
best suited for anticoagulation in areas of slowly flowing blood such as veins
and the pooled blood behind artificial and natural valves and dysfunctional
cardiac atria. It is commonly used to prevent DVT and pulmonary embolism, and
against stroke in atrial fibrillation (AF), valvular heart disease, and
artificial heart valves. It is additionally used following ST-segment elevation
myocardial infarction and orthopedic surgeries. Initiation regimens are simple,
safe, and suitable to be used in the ambulatory settings [90]. It should be
initiated with a 5 mg dose, or 2 to 4 mg in the elderlies. In the protocol of
low-dose warfarin, the target international normalized ratio (INR) is between
2.0 and 2.5, whereas in the protocol of standard-dose warfarin, the target INR
is between 2.5 and 3.5 [91]. Simple discontinuation of the drug for five days
is enough to reverse the effect, and causes INR to drop below 1.5 [92]. Its
effects can be reversed with phytomenadione (vitamin K1), fresh frozen plasma,
or prothrombin complex concentrate, rapidly. Warfarin decreases blood clotting
by blocking vitamin K epoxide reductase, an ezyme that reactivates vitamin K1.
Without sufficient active vitamin K1, abilities of clotting factors II, VII,
IX, and X are decreased. The abilities of anticlotting protein C and S are also
inhibited, but to a lesser degree. A few days are required for full effect
which is lasting up to five days. The consensus agrees that current
self-testing and management devices are effective providing outcomes possibly
better than achieved, clinically. The risk of severe bleeding is just 1-3%,
annually, and the severest ones are those involving the central nervous system [92,93].
The risk is particularly increased once the INR exceeds 4.5 [93]. The risk of
bleeding is increased further when warfarin is combined with antiplatelet drugs
such as clopidogrel or aspirin [94]. Thirteen publications from 11 cohorts
including more than 48.500 patients with more than 11.600 warfarin users were
included in the meta-analysis in which warfarin resulted with a lower risk of
ischemic stroke (p= 0.004) and mortality (p<0.00001), but had no effect on
major bleeding (p>0.05) in patients with AF and non-end-stage CRD [95].
Warfarin is associated with significant reductions in ischemic stroke even in
patients with warfarin-associated intracranial hemorrhage (ICH) [96]. On the
other hand, patients with cerebral venous thrombosis (CVT) anticoagulated either
with warfarin or dabigatran had lower risk of recurrent venous thrombotic
events (VTE), and the risks of bleeding were similar in both regimens [97].
Additionally, an INR value of 1.5 achieved with an average daily dose of 4.6 mg
warfarin, has resulted with no increase in the number of men ever reporting
minor bleeding episodes [98]. Non-rheumatic AF increases the risk of stroke,
and long-term use of low-dose warfarin is highly effective and safe with a
reduction of 86% (p= 0.0022) [99]. The mortality rate was significantly lower
in the warfarin group, too (p= 0.005) [99]. The frequencies of bleedings that
required hospitalization or transfusions were similar in both groups
(p>0.05) [99]. Additionally, very-low-dose warfarin was safe and effective
for prevention of thromboembolism in metastatic breast cancer in which the
average daily dose was 2.6 mg, and the mean INR value was 1.5 [100]. On the
other hand, new oral anticoagulants had a favorable risk-benefit profile with
significant reductions in stroke, ICH, and mortality, and with similar major
bleedings as for warfarin, but increased GI bleeding [101]. Interestingly,
rivaroxaban and low-dose apixaban were associated with increased risks of
all-cause mortality compared with warfarin [102]. The mortality rates were
4.1%, 3.7%, and 3.6% per year in the warfarin, 110 mg of dabigatran, and 150 mg
of dabigatran groups with AF, respectively (p>0.05 for both) [103].
Eventually, infection, inflammation, medical or surgical emergency, and
emotional stress-induced increased basal metabolic rate accelerates sickling,
and an exaggerated capillary endothelial edema-induced myocardial infarction or
stroke may cause sudden deaths [104]. So anti-inflammatory dose of aspirin plus
low-dose warfarin may be the other life-saving drug regimen to prevent
atherosclerotic endpoints even at childhood in the SCD [105].
COPD
is the third leading cause of death at the moment [106]. Aging, smoking,
alcohol, male gender, excess fat tissue, chronic inflammation, prolonged
infection, and cancers may be the underlying causes. Atherosclerotic effects of
smoking may be the most obvious in the COPD and Buerger’s disease, probably due
to the higher concentrations of toxic substances in the lungs and pooling of
blood in the extremities. After smoking, excess fat tissue may be the second
common cause of COPD due to the excess fat tissue-induced atherosclerotic
endpoints in whole body since an estimated 25-45% of patients with the COPD
have never smoked [107]. Regular alcohol consumption may be the third leading
cause of the systemic exaggerated atherosclerotic process and COPD, since COPD
was one of the most common diagnoses in alcohol dependence [108]. Furthermore,
30-day readmission rates were higher in the COPD patients with alcoholism [109].
Probably an accelerated atherosclerotic process is the main structural
background of functional changes that are characteristics of the COPD. The
inflammatory process of vascular endothelial cells is exaggerated by release of
various chemicals by inflammatory cells, and it terminates with an advanced
fibrosis, atherosclerosis, and pulmonary losses. COPD may just be the pulmonary
endpoint of the systemic atherosclerotic process since there are several
reports about coexistence of associated endothelial inflammation in whole body
in the COPD [110]. For example, there may be close relationships between COPD,
CHD, PAD, and stroke [111]. Furthermore, two-third of mortality cases were
caused by cardiovascular diseases and lung cancers in the COPD, and the CHD was
the most common cause in a multicenter study of 5.887 smokers [112]. When
hospitalizations were researched, the most common causes were the
cardiovascular diseases, again [112]. In another study, 27% of mortality cases
were due to the cardiovascular diseases in the moderate and severe COPD [113].
Finally, COPD may also be an irreversible atherosclerotic endpoint in the SCD [106].
Leg
ulcers are seen in 10% to 20% of patients with the SCD, and its prevalence
increases with aging, male gender, and SCA [114, 115]. The leg ulcers have an
intractable nature, and around 97% of them relapse in one year (114). Similar
to Buerger's disease, the leg ulcers occur in the distal segments of the body
with a lesser collateral blood flow [114]. The hardened RBC-induced chronic
endothelial damage, inflammation, edema, and fibrosis at the capillaries may be
the main causes [115]. Prolonged exposure to the hardened bodies due to the
pooling of blood in the lower extremities may also explain the leg but not arm
ulcers in the SCD. The hardened RBC-induced venous insufficiencies may also
accelerate the process by pooling of causative bodies in the legs, and vice
versa. Pooling of blood may also be important for the development of venous
ulcers, diabetic ulcers, Buerger’s disease, digital clubbing, and onychomycosis
in the lower extremities. Furthermore, pooling of blood may be the cause of
delayed wound and fracture healings in the lower extremities. Smoking and
alcohol probably have some additional atherosclerotic effects on the leg ulcers
in males. Although presence of a continuous damage of hardened RBC on vascular
endothelial cells, severity of the destructive process is probably exaggerated
by the immune system. The main action way of hydroxyurea may be the suppression
of hyperproliferative WBC and PLT in the SCD [77,116]. Similarly, lower WBC
counts were associated with lower crisis rates, and if a tissue infarct occurs,
lower WBC counts may decrease severity of tissue damage and pain [78].
Prolonged resolution of leg ulcers with hydroxyurea may also suggest that the
ulcers may be secondary to increased WBC and PLT counts-induced exaggerated
capillary endothelial cell edema. Digital clubbing is characterized by the
increased normal angle of 165° between the nailbed and fold, increased
convexity of the nail fold, and thickening of the whole distal finger [117].
The chronic tissue hypoxia is highly suspected in its etiology [118]. In the
previous study, only 40% of clubbing cases turned out to have significant
underlying diseases while 60% remained well over the subsequent years [18]. But
according to our experiences, digital clubbing is frequently associated with
the smoking and pulmonary, cardiac, renal, and hepatic diseases which are
characterized with chronic tissue hypoxia [5]. As an explanation for that
hypothesis, lungs, heart, kidneys, and liver are closely related organs those
can affect their functions in a short period of time. On the other hand,
digital clubbing is also common in the SCD, too and its prevalence is 10.8% in
the present study. It probably shows chronic tissue hypoxia caused by
disseminated endothelial damage, edema, and fibrosis, particularly at the
capillary level in the SCD. Beside the effects of SCD, smoking, alcohol,
cirrhosis, CRD, CHD, and COPD, the higher prevalence of clubbing in males
(14.8% vs 6.6%, p<0.001) may also indicate some additional role of male
gender for the atherosclerotic endpoints.
CRD
is increasing which can be explained by prolonged survival and increased
prevalence of excess fat tissue, too [119]. Aging, animal-rich diet, excess fat
tissue, smoking, alcohol, chronic inflammatory or infectious process, and
cancers may be the major causes of the renal endothelial inflammation, too. The
inflammatory process is enhanced by release of various chemicals by lymphocytes
to repair the damaged endothelial cells of the renal arteriols. Due to the
continuous irritation of the vascular endothelial cells, prominent changes
develop in the architecture of the renal tissues with advanced atherosclerosis,
tissue hypoxia, and infarcts [120]. Excess fat tissue-induced hyperglycemia,
dyslipidemia, elevated BP, and insulin resistance can cause tissue inflammation
and immune cell activation [121]. Age (p= 0.04), high-sensitivity CRP (p=
0.01), mean arterial BP (p= 0.003), and DM (p= 0.02) had significant
correlations with the CIMT [119]. Increased renal tubular sodium reabsorption,
impaired pressure natriuresis, volume expansion due to the activations of
sympathetic nervous system and renin-angiotensin system, and physical
compression of kidneys by visceral fat tissue may be some mechanisms of the
increased BP with excess fat tissue [122]. Excess fat tissue also causes renal
vasodilation and glomerular hyperfiltration which initially serve as
compensatory mechanisms to maintain sodium balance due to the increased tubular
reabsorption [122]. However, along with the increased BP, these changes cause a
hemodynamic burden on the kidneys in long term that causes chronic endothelial
damage [123]. With prolonged excess fat tissue, there are increased urinary
protein excretion, loss of nephron function, and exacerbated HT. With the
development of dyslipidemia and DM, CRD progresses more easily [122]. The
systemic inflammatory effects of smoking on endothelial cells is also important
in the CRD [124]. Although the presence of some opposite reports [124], alcohol
probably gives harm to the renal vascular endothelium, too. Chronic
inflammatory or infectious processes may also terminate with atherosclerotic
endpoints in kidneys [123]. There are close relationships between CRD and other
atherosclerotic endpoints [125,126]. The most common causes of death were CHD
and stroke in CRD, again [127]. The hardened RBC-induced capillary endothelial
damage may be the major cause of CRD in the SCD, again [128].
Stroke
is the other terminal cause of death, together with the CHD, and it develops as
an acute thromboembolic event on the chronic atherosclerotic background. Aging,
male gender, smoking, alcohol, excess fat tissue, chronic inflammatory or
infectious process, cancer, and emotional stress may be the major causes.
Stroke is also a common atherosclerotic endpoint of the SCD [129]. Similar to
the leg ulcers, stroke is particularly higher in cases with the SCA and higher
WBC counts [130]. Sickling-induced capillary endothelial damage, activations of
WBC, PLT, and coagulation system, and hemolysis may terminate with chronic
capillary endothelial damage, edema, and fibrosis [131]. Stroke may not have a
macrovascular origin, and an acute onset diffuse capillary endothelial edema
may be much more important in the SCD. Therefore, permanent neurological
deficits are rare with stroke in the SCD. Infection, inflammation, medical or
surgical emergency, and emotional stress may cause stroke by increasing basal
metabolic rate and sickling. Low risk of stroke with hydroxyurea can also
suggest that a significant proportion of stroke is developed due to the
increased WBC and PLT counts-induced an acute capillary endothelial edema [132].
Acarbose is a pseudotetrasaccharide produced as a natural microbial product of
Actinophages strain SE 50. It binds to oligosaccharide binding site of
alpha-glucosidase enzymes in the brush border of the small intestinal mucosa
with a dose-dependent manner, reversibly and competitively. It inhibits
glucoamylase, sucrase, maltase, dextranase, and pancreatic alpha-amylase. It
has little affinity for isomaltose but does not have any effect on
beta-glucosidases such as lactase. By this way, it delays the intestinal
hydrolysis of oligo- and disaccharides mainly in the upper half of the small
intestine. As a result, the absorption of monosaccharides is delayed, and
transport into the circulation is interrupted. Its effects may prolong up to 5
hours. The suppression of alpha-glucosidases is persistent with long-term use.
Its usage results with carbohydrates appearing in the colon where bacterial
fermentation occurs, and causes flatulence, loose stool, and abdominal
discomfort [133]. If started with a lower dosage and titrated slowly, side
effects are tolerable [134]. Long-term use increases colonic bacterial mass
that of lacto bacteria in particular. The finally impaired carbohydrate
absorption, increased bacterial carbohydrate fermentation, and fecal
acidification mimic effects of lactulose in portosystemic encephalopathy. So
acarbose has a favorable therapeutic profile for the long-term use even in
cirrhosis. Similarly, observed changes in bacterial flora and decreased stool
pH and beta-hydroxybutyrate may be associated with anti-proliferative effects
on the epithelial cells of colon that may potentially decrease carcinogenesis.
After oral administration, less than 2% of the unchanged drug enters into the
circulation. Therefore, there is no need for dosage adjustment in mild renal
insufficiency. After a high carbohydrate meal, acarbose lowers the postprandial
rise in blood glucose by 20% and secondarily FPG by 15% [135]. The initial
improvement in blood glucose tends to be modest, but efficacy steadily improves
with the long-term use. Its beneficial effects on serum lipids were also seen
with a dose-dependent manner [135], because dietary carbohydrates are key
precursors of lipogenesis, and insulin plays a central role for postprandial
lipid metabolism. Carbohydrate-induced postprandial triglycerides synthesis is
reduced for several hours, so acarbose lowers plasma triglycerides levels [135].
The same beneficial effect is also seen in non-diabetic patients with
hypertriglyceridemia, and acarbose reduced LDL significantly, and HDL remained
as unchanged in hyper insulinemic and overweight patients with impaired glucose
tolerance (IGT) [136]. Significantly elevated Urso cholic acids in the stool
appear to be the additive endpoint of a decreased rate of absorption and
increased intestinal motility due to the changes of intestinal flora. Acarbose
may lower LDL via increased fecal bifido bacteria and biliary acids. Acarbose
together with insulin was identified to be associated with a greater
improvement in the oxidative stress and inflammation in DM [137]. Probably,
acarbose improves release of glucagon-like peptide-1, inhibits PLT activation,
increases epithelial nitrous oxide synthase activity and nitrous oxide
concentrations, promotes weight loss, decreases BP, and eventually prevents
endothelial dysfunction [135]. So, it prevents atherosclerotic endpoints of
excess fat tissue even in the absence of IGT or DM [138,139]. Although some
authors reported as opposite [140], it should be used as the first-line
antidiabetic agent. Based on more than 40 years of use, numerous studies did
not show any significant side effect or toxicity [141]. Although 25.9% of
patients stopped metformin due to excessive anorexia [142], only 10.6% stopped
acarbose due to an excessive flatulence or loose stool [143].
Metformin
is a biguanide, and it is not metabolized, and 90% of absorbed drug is
eliminated as unchanged in the urine. Plasma protein binding is negligible, so
the drug is dialyzable. According to literature, antihyperglycemic effect of
metformin is largely caused by inhibition of hepatic gluconeogenesis, increased
insulin-mediated glucose disposal, inhibition of fatty acid oxidation, and
reduction of intestinal glucose absorption [144, 145]. Precise mechanism of
intracellular action of metformin remains as unknown. Interestingly, 25.9% of
patients stopped metformin due to the excessively lost appetite [142].
Additionally, 14.1% of patients with overweight or obesity in the metformin
group rose either to normal weight or overweight group by weight loss without a
diet regimen [142]. According to our opinion, the major effect of metformin is
an inhibition of appetite. Similar results indicating the beneficial effects on
the BMI, BP, FPG, and lipids were also reported [146,147]. Probably the major
component of the metabolic syndrome may be the excess fat tissue. So, treatment
of excess fat tissue with acarbose plus metformin will probably prevent not
only IGT or DM but also the other atherosclerotic endpoints. As a conclusion,
hardened RBC-induced capillary endothelial damage terminates with end-organ
insufficiencies in early decades of life in SCD. Although atherosclerotic
endpoints are so common, we detected no case of DM probably due to lower excess
fat tissue. As the most common cause of CRD, DM may be a relative insufficiency
of pancreas against the excess fat tissue. Increased blood and insulin
requirements of excess fat in contrast to decreased blood supply of excess
tissue and pancreas both due to excess external pressure and internal narrowing
of vasculature may be important for DM. As the most common cause of DM, obesity
may be an irreversible atherosclerotic endpoint in human body. Acarbose and
metformin are oral, safe, cheap, and effective drugs to prevent obesity.