Article Type : Research Article
Authors : Votta M, Quaggia D, Satinder Phull MPH and Dhullipala M
Keywords : Civic activism; Vaccination policy; Immunization; Patients’ rights; Civil Society Organisations (CSOs); Patient Advocacy Groups (PAGs); Hard-to-reach populations; Hepatitis; Meningitis; Vaccine preventable respiratory diseases (VPRD); Shingles; Pneumococcal vaccination; Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV); Chronic conditions
What do a Quality Charter and a website have in
common? Or an Observatory with civic consultations? How do you structure an
information campaign for the benefit of chronic patients as opposed to young
students? What should we pay particular attention to when addressing the
elderly rather than disadvantaged, isolated, and hard-to-reach populations? The
answers to these and other questions, when we talk about vaccination policies,
are contained in the experiences collected by Cittadinanzattiva-Active Citizenship
and published in a handbook which highlights the active role of civil society
in supporting public policy on vaccination. Many actors from intermediary
bodies in society can play a constructive role, be the driving force, with
institutional and non-institutional stakeholders. Various initiatives
demonstrate their activism in the vaccination space. To promote these efforts
at European level, Active Citizenship Network, the EU branch of Italian NGO
Cittadinanzattiva, has published a handbook edited and designed by MD Health.
It contains a range of activities to help those who want to invest more in
prevention and immunization but don't know where to start.
The
WHO has defined community engagement as “a process of developing relationships
that enable stakeholders to work together to address health-related issues and
promote well-being to achieve positive health impact and outcomes”, and it
underlines the “Community and civil society engagement” as a pillar of its
“Global Action Plan for Healthy Lives and Well-being for All” [1]. In December
2023, when the European Commission adopted the EU4Health 2024 work program to
implement key health policy priorities within the European Health Union, Stella
Kyriakides, European Commissioner for Health and Food Safety, emphasised that
"Civil society has a crucial role to play in reaching out to our
citizens" [2]. This principle applies even more strongly to vaccination
policies, as the COVID-19 pandemic demonstrated. Policymakers echoed this view:
at the G7 Ministers’ Meeting on Health held on 9-11 October 2024 in Ancona
(Italy). Global leaders stated: “We stress that vaccination is an essential
preventive measure and reiterate the crucial role of routine immunisation and
campaigns”. They highlighted “the importance of raising awareness and involving
the general population by providing evidence-based information through
campaigns aimed at citizens’ empowerment and increasing health literacy
regarding prevention, research and care” [3].
V.I.P.
for life-course immunisation promotion
The Vaccination Informal Platform (V.I.P.) for life-course immunisation promotion is a collective of leaders from patient and citizen organisations across Europe, promoted by Active Citizenship Network [4,5], the EU branch of the Italian NGO Cittadinanzattiva [5], as part of the multi-annual EU project #VaccinAction [6]. For several years, the group has united periodically in Brussels with the aim of strengthening the exchange of experiences among the diverse organisations to support public vaccination policies. These meetings [7-10], held twice a year, have facilitated the exchange of practical advocacy experiences in immunisation policies (Figure 1).
Figure 1: Online form for gatering experiences.
Figure
2: Cover of the handbook.
As
well as highlighted the need to collect, catalogue and showcase these examples
of civic activism. Hence the idea of a handbook. To better harmonise the
information, a useful online format has been created. The handbook follows a
well-established tradition spanning over 40 years at the Italian NGO
Cittadinanzattiva, which promotes citizens' activism for the protection of
rights, the care of common goods and the support for people in vulnerable
situations, at the national and at the EU level [11]. It was created as part of
the fifth edition of our EU project “#VaccinAction - Protecting the Value of
Vaccination Across Europe” [12] which focusses on strengthening adult
vaccination and safeguarding the value of routine immunization across Europe.
It also draws on the continuous exchange of experiences among leaders of
patient and citizen organisations (Figure 2).
It is not a manual, nor does it aim to highlight and disseminate best practices (this will likely be the next step in this initiative). Rather, it is deliberately a concise document offering a range of different types of activities for the benefit of those who feel the need to do more in terms of prevention and immunization, but do not know where to start. In total, 16 experiences are included, most of them from Europe [13]. Each one provides detailed information across the following areas: project overview; challenges addressed; stakeholders involved; methodology; results; links & resources; and implementation. Qualitative evaluations are also included, covering the following areas: what was done; what changed; and what to keep in mind (Figure 3).
Figure
3: The same template was used for each experience to
capture the following: project title & leading organisation details
(including logo, website & country location).
Figure 4: Vaccination Informal Platform (V.I.P.) meeting: 25 June 2024, Brussels.
Figure 5: Save the date of the 2nd Vaccination Informal Platform (V.I.P.) meeting on 2024, realised on 15 of October in Brussels (Belgium).
Figure 6: Vaccination Informal Platform (V.I.P.) meeting: 2 October 2025, Brussels (Belgium).
Figure
7: Vaccination Informal Platform (V.I.P.) meeting: 3
December 2025, Brussels (Belgium).
What you will find in the handbook
These
are concrete experiences, not ideas or recommendations, but expressions of
civic activism. They are diverse in several ways: some are supported by
EU-funded projects, while many are funded by private entities; some were
implemented before COVID-19 pandemic and others after; and while most were
implemented across EU Member States, some were undertaken outside the EU. They
also differ in terms of their geographical impact - some are purely local, many
have a national scope and a few are European in reach. The target audiences
vary too. Some initiatives are aimed specifically at the adult population,
while others at young students. Additional focus placed on chronic patients,
disadvantaged and isolated groups, hard-to-reach populations (such as refugees,
migrants and prisoners), policymakers or the general public. The specific
subject matter also differs. Some experiences focus on specific vaccination,
such as meningitis, shingles, pneumococcal, hepatitis B or respiratory
syncytial virus (RSV). Others, which we have categorized as “vaccination
policy”, encompass a broader spectrum of activities, including vaccines against
infectious respiratory diseases, addressing vaccination hesitancy, increasing
uptake and improving access. In short, these experiences are deliberately
varied, but they share an underlying unifying message: the necessity - not just
the usefulness - of involving organized civil society in public health. This is
the unifying thread among the organizations that collaborate with Active Citizenship
Network in the Vaccination Informal Platform (V.I.P.) (Figure 4-7).
Who
is it aimed at and for what purpose?
The
handbook is aimed primarily at the many voices of civil society who, by
browsing a catalogue of opportunities and reading about concrete, established
experiences, may feel encouraged to become more active in supporting public
vaccination policies within their own communities. The main aim of the booklet
is to demonstrate, in a practical way, how intermediary bodies of the society,
when recognized as a stakeholder, can play an active role in support of public
policy on vaccination. The ultimate goal is to broaden the narrative around
vaccination, which tends to focus on hesitant or hostile attitudes, while
overlooking the active and constructive role played by Civil Society
Organisations (CSOs) and Patient Advocacy Groups (PAGs). This handbook aims to
show that civil society is part of the solution.
Each of the authors confirms that this manuscript has not been previously published by another international peer-review journal and is not under consideration by any other peer-review journal. Additionally, all of the authors have approved the contents of this paper and have agreed to the submission policies of the journal.
Authors’ Contribution
Each named author has substantially contributed to managing the described initiative and drafting this manuscript.
To
the best of our knowledge, the named authors listed on the first page declare
that they do not have any conflict of interest, financial or otherwise.
This
publication received no direct funding. The activities described took part of
the EU project “#VaccinAction - Protecting the Value of Vaccination Across
Europe”, carried out by Cittadinanzattiva-Active Citizenship Network and
realized thanks to the unconditional support of CSL Seqirus, GSK, MSD, Pfizer,
Sanofi.
The
authors gratefully acknowledge the associations who wanted to share their
experiences, by participating in information gathering.