Article Type : Review Article
Authors : Mims D and Waddell R
Keywords : Animal assisted therapy; Service animals; Prison animal training
The purpose of this qualitative
study was to explore the perceptions of prison inmates participating in the
Paws and Stripes College program. The Paws and Stripes College program involves
incarcerated inmates training local humane shelter canines’ obedience training techniques
using the AKC Canine Good Citizen model. Using secondary data from self-report
questionnaires completed by the inmates, this study sought to explore how the
inmates felt before and after their exposure to the Paws and Stripes College
program. Specifically, if the inmates felt that participation in the program
had helped them or not, and if so, how. The Paws and Stripes College program
revealed a positive impact on inmate increased knowledge and skills in animal
training, leading them to better communication, conflict resolution, and
interpersonal behaviours which can enhance future employability. Homeless
canines benefited by finding valued homes to care for them while providing a
useful service to families and those with special needs. The community benefits
from improvements in inmate behaviour while incarcerated and their productivity
toward their family members and society once released. Subsequently, special
populations were served by the trained canines as animal assisted therapy dogs
for child welfare programs and for veterans that suffered with the side effects
of trauma.
Generally, the public is motivated by one concept in
dealing with prisoners: punishment.
The mission of the Federal Prison system is to “...
protect society by confining offenders in the controlled environments of
prisons and community-based facilities that are safe, humane, cost-efficient,
and appropriately secure, and that provide work and other self-improvement
opportunities to assist offenders in becoming law-abiding citizens” [1]. The
public gives little thought to rehabilitation until confronted with the
escalating cost of incarcerating and re-offending individuals. Rehabilitation
of prisoners and the ability to reintegrate into society must be a priority if
we want to make offending individuals functioning members of society while
lowering the financial cost to the community. We must consider novel approaches
to rehabilitating felons, including using dogs, horses, and other animals to
teach inmates life-enhancing skills [2]. Rehabilitation of prisoners is
necessary in order to exert positive changes in attitudes, behaviours and
assist with reintegration into society [3]. The purpose of this Paws and
Stripes College program was to explore the perceptions of prison inmates
utilizing canines from the local humane society. Using secondary data from
self-report questionnaires completed by the inmates, this study sought to
explore how the inmates felt before and after their exposure to the Paws and
Stripes College program. Specifically, if the inmates felt that participation
in the program had helped them or not, and if so, how.
Project Pooch was one of the first programs to bring
incarcerated juveniles together with abandoned and abused dogs. Joan Dalton,
Principle of McLaren Juvenile Correctional Facility in Woodburn, Oregon started
the first Project Pooch program in 1993. In 1999, Project Pooch obtained
non-profit status and hired a project manager. Students who participated in the
Project Pooch program learned long lasting life skills. Not only did they learn
dog grooming and canine training but they studied the health and well-being of
animals. The inmates worked and performed duties by assisting with the
operation of a boarding kennel where the dogs received training and were
grooming upon discharge. The skills ascertained by working in the kennel and
training the canines and be utilized in most communities because boarding and
grooming facilities are a commodity in constant need [4].
Prisons and juvenile detention centres across America
and globally have begun to implement animal-training programs in which inmates
are able to train a wide variety of animals for service positions. Many of the
canines trained within the prison walls have gone on to:
1. To
assist the physically challenged persons (i.e., Blind, Deaf, Mobility
Impaired);
2. To
assist mentally challenged persons (i.e., depressed, anxious, PTSD, lonely);
3. To
assist Police agencies and the Military;
4. To
be Canine Good Citizens for Families;
5. To
be therapy dogs for use in nursing and retirement homes, schools and
counselling;
6. To
rehabilitate Race Horses and Wild Mustangs;
7. And
in therapeutic treatment planning [5].
Pioneer David Lee started the first successful animal
therapy program in Lima, Ohio in 1975 in a United States Prison at the Oakwood
Forensic Centre (formerly the Lima State Hospital for the Criminally Insane)
after he noticed inmates caring for an injured bird. He began a 90-day study
comparing patients with pets, to patients without pets and the results exceeded
expectation: research showed reduced incidents of violence, decreased use of
medications, and lessened the number of suicide attempts. Ultimately, his
prison program went on to train the first guide dogs and ran a large successful
farm [5].
Dr. Leo Bustard and Kathy Quine (known as Sister
Pauline), were two pioneers who laid the foundation for starting over 17 dog
training programs in different correctional facilities throughout the United
States. The benefits derived from their dog training programs included: inmates
increased self-esteem, increased marketable work skills, and increased earned
college credit. An additional benefit of the program was that dogs from the
local Humane Society were spared euthanasia and had a productive life by being
trained to be service dogs for people with special needs [2].
Jennifer Wesely, a professor of criminology at the
University of North Florida, conducted research that demonstrated the positive
behavioural effects of prison animal programs (PAPs). These behavioural effects
include enhanced empathy, emotional intelligence, improved communication
skills, greater patience, self-control and trust. Wesely, who is studying focus
groups of inmates who have participated in the program, is looking at how the
program can affect "criminogenic masculinity."
Professor Wesely researched the idea that some
marginalized men grow up in conditions or cultures where they don't have access
"to the mainstream ways to be a man" and "learn lessons through
abuse, poverty and social exclusion." Professor Wesely noted in her
research that a majority of the inmates had early lessons in masculinity and
learned through very abusive behaviours that they could never show weakness.
Many learned they had to kind of shut down that aspect of their identity in
order to survive out in the streets [6].
The focus of this inmate animal training study took
place at the Brevard County Sheriff’s Office in Melbourne, Florida which
operates the Paws and Stripes College, rescuing shelter dogs and training them
to be adoptable family and/or service dogs for veterans. Many of these programs
are non-profit and are funded through donations, grants, animal-protection
groups, and dedicated volunteers. The community volunteers assist the inmates’
training program by taking the dogs on trips outside the prison to get them
used to different environments, people, and in many cases working environments
they would not find within the prison walls.
Research
design
The researchers utilized a qualitative
phenomenological design to gather data. The Secondary data involved
self-reported questionnaires which were collected by prison staff. The
utilization of self-report questionnaires was designed to address research
questions about the inmates’ perception of their involvement in the Paws and
Stripes College program. A subjective approach [7] allows the researchers to
gain insight into the perceptions of the participating inmates in the program.
Nine open-ended questionnaires were completed by a combination of both male and
female adult inmates who were actively engaged in the Paws and Stripes College
program. The inmates’ responses focused on the benefits and challenges of
participating in the Paws and Stripes College program and sought to explore how
the inmates felt before and after their exposure to the Paws on Parole program.
Specifically, the study sought to understand if the
inmates felt that participation in the program had helped them or not, and if
so, how. The researchers’ study received Institutional Review Board approval
from the correctional facility for the project. Informed consent was obtained
from all participants prior to initiating interviews.
Participant
selection
The study explored nine canine handler questionnaires previously
completed by incarcerated adult male and female participants 18 years and older
incarcerated at the Melbourne, Florida Correctional Institute. The inmates
consisted of various ethnic groups, who had a history of direct human or
property violence. Participants at the time of the study were incarcerated
inmates of the Melbourne Florida Correctional Institute who had willingly
volunteered to participate in the study and had been actively involved in the
Paws and Stripes College program for animal training. The training sessions
were performed by a certified dog training professional participating in the
program for at least one year. The survey was self-administered by the Brevard
County Paws and Stripes College program participant inmates and no personal
identifiers of the inmates were included on the surveys. The questionnaire
surveys were subsequently collected by the Principal Investigator and
Co-Principal Investigator. The secondary collected and reviewed data will be
kept confidently secured for 7 years in a locked file draw behind a locked
office door in the Principle Investigator’s Office and will only be accessed by
the researchers on the team.
Data
collection
Data was gathered using a researcher-designed
questionnaire containing questions focused on the impact of the Paws and
Stripes College program on various aspects of inmates' communication, conflict
resolution, and interpersonal behaviours.
The inmate's responses focused on their perceptions
about how the Paws and Stripes College program impacted their lives inside
prison, their hopes for their lives outside of prison, and how it affected the
animals being trained. More specifically, the inmates were asked to reveal if
they felt participation in the program had influenced them and if so, how it
had altered their lives; or if not, why not.
Data
analysis
All questionnaires were transcribed verbatim. A
three-step process [8] was used to analyse the data gathered from interviews.
Triangulation (through researcher memoing, coding, and peer debriefing as an
audit trail), was used to analyse the data gathered from interviews. Open
coding was used to identify 30 common ideas and experiences expressed by
participants during the answering of questions. Subsequently; the individual
categories were “coded” with descriptive labels.
Next, axial coding was used to condense the number of
categories identified during open coding, by combining categories with similar
ideas. Lastly, selective coding was used to identify core ideas present in the
previously-identified themes from the categories. Both researchers participated
in the coding process. If researchers did not initially agree on the chosen
themes, the coding process was reinitiated by reviewing and discussing common
ideas, which were then condensed to more relevant categories that both
researchers agreed upon.
Main Themes can be categorized into Four broad themes
emerged from the data:
Inmates
benefits
1. Therapeutic
Responses: Reduced inmate’s stressors of being in jail; increased inmates’
patience; increase inmate’s sense of community purpose.
2. Job
Skills: Increase potential inmate employability in work with animals, increase
inmate’s knowledge of animal training skills for personal usage with work with
own/family animals.
Canine
benefits
Shelter dog's obedience training making them more
adoptable; dogs’ service training skills make them more adoptable; increased
adoptions of shelter dogs and decreased chances for euthanasia.
Prison
facility benefits
Improves inmates’ satisfaction with doing prison time
reducing problem behaviour; increases the inmates' visibility and appreciation
by the community; increases positive communication between prison staff and
inmates.
Inmates
recommendations for changes in the paws and stripes program
No Dogs Should is Returned to the Shelter: “Stop dogs
not adopted from having to be returned to the shelter”; expand on dog training
schedules making them more evenly distributed; and allows dogs to be housed
with inmates to increase social skills in the canines.
Inmate
Perceptions (participants’ surveys were anonymous to maintain confidentiality)
The survey questionnaire exposed the positive
influence and importance of a rehabilitative program for incarcerated inmates.
Every survey collected and reviewed disclosed 100% that inmates felt the
experience they received from the Paws and Stripes program positively changed
their lives. The participants expressed they felt more confident in their
abilities and communication skills to be able to live more productively in
society. In addition, they convened their opinions of the value this program
had on the community. By taking animals that were essentially unadoptable from
the humane society and teaching them basic obedience skills, it created a more
socially compatible pet that was more prone to be adopted. The Paws and Stripes
Program was seen by the participants as a win-win situation for both society
and incarcerated inmates.
Findings
Direct quotes from Inmates: (no participants’ names
were known to the researchers to further protect the inmates’ confidentiality).
1. “Maybe
I’ll try to get a job in this area of work. Train and handle my dog correctly.
Talk to people about their dogs, teach them what I have learned”.
2. “The
many times I have visited shelters I would always think to myself how cool it
would be to work with animals, especially those in need of love and proper
attention. Now I feel that with all the knowledge I have I would qualify for a
job handling the animals.”
3. “This
program has absolutely changed my life. I have learned to love myself and other
people, realizing none of us are perfect and if we fail, we pick you up and try
again. I have developed patience and tolerance a willingness to overcome them. I
have learned to be victorious rather than defeated.”
4. “Yes,
Paws and Stripes is therapeutic, spending time with the dogs affected me and
the dogs in a positive way. Making a difference in the lives of people that
need our dogs, once they get adopted helped to give me self-confidence”.
5. “Having
a program like this is such an asset to the community. These dogs become
helpers and healers and it’s really amazing to see them get matched up with a
person who needs them. It helps the dogs to.”
6. “Initially
I was apprehensive about training the dogs because they have such important
jobs to do. I was nervous about messing up their training, but Deputy Fay (Mrs.
Muller) & Corporal Lamp helped to ease my nervousness and teach me in a
respectful way which gave me confidence to train”.
7. “Dogs
shouldn’t get sent back to the shelter because they didn’t have anyone looking
to adopt them, we should just continue to train the dog”.
8. “Bitter
sweet, because I’m happy they found a home, but sad at the same time because I
get attached to them”.
Participants’ responses regarding their experiences
with the Paws and Stripes College program results indicated that this
particular inmate animal prison program provided therapeutic benefits to the
inmates by improving their time spent in jail due to reducing stressors such as
boredom, depression, and anxiety. The program was instrumental in increasing
the inmate's confidence and improving their communication skills through a
self-expressed sense of purpose, and perceived job enhancement through the
development of employable skills (canine training, grooming, and animal
behaviour). The inmates also developed skills not just limited to canine
training, but skills that would help them adjust to the outside world through
expansion of responsible behaviour, patience and empathetic caring toward another
living entity. Most importantly, the inmates learned to respect themselves and
others while building trust, confidence and independence in both canines and
humans.
The participants in this study discussed difficulties
functioning within their prison environment with regard to both coping and
communication skills. The Paws and Stripes College program appeared to help the
participants become more conscious of, and more mindful of their various
emotions. Through learning how to process and manage their emotions during
their work in animal training, the inmates were better able to effectively
utilize appropriate interpersonal and communication skills. In turn, the
inmates’ felt this made them more compassionate and successful trainers while
helping to approach and resolve conflict within their daily interactions with
staff and each other. In addition, all nine participants discussed the value of
learning to work together with an animal in order to achieve successful
alternative outcomes. In particular, several participants discussed the
benefits of spending time with different canines, as they felt this helped them
learn to understand and interact with different personalities and challenges.
Inmates expressed feeling that working with different breeds and temperaments of canines helped them learn to interact with people with different personalities in their families and within the current prison environment.
The participants noted that humans can be judgmental, and many times they are judged for being incarcerated. The inmates expressed that although they had committed crimes, that the majority of people do not understand the individual situations that led them to committing a criminal act. The inmates reported the Paws and Stripes College program environment and the presence of a non-judgmental animal provided them a sense of security, allowing for self-exploration of their behaviors and choices in life which ultimately affected their understanding of themselves and of others.
The human-animal interaction
component proves to be a unique aspect utilized in the Paws and Stripes College
program and may contribute to its effectiveness. The current study revealed how
the Paws and Stripes College program helps to improve inmates’ communication
skills, conflict resolution strategies and interpersonal behaviors within their
lives, and has been proven to benefit the shelter animals as well. The shelter
animals improve their obedience skills, social skills, and their trained
purpose to serve those with specific needs such as veterans with PTSD and
children within the protective services system. These canines find and provide
companionship and value to individuals, families, and their communities, no
longer facing euthanasia and being unwanted.
Additional research is needed to
explore the process by which Paws on Parole College program helps improve the
inmates’ behaviour while they are incarcerated and a follow up study conducted
after they are released in order to see the influence on society [9].
Furthermore, experimental studies comparing the Paws and Stripes College
program to other forms of prison training programs utilized with this
population would highlight the relative effectiveness of this approach.
An additional study comparing animal
training programs versus more traditional forms of prison vocational training
programs is warranted. Most importantly, we must understand that the Paws and
Stripes College program, like many others, produces a “…. win-win situation:
It’s good for the dogs, often adopted from shelters where they might otherwise
be euthanized and it’s a wonderful gift for special populations of individuals
who can ultimately experience a new world of freedom with a dog at their side. Canines,
now trained, can assist mobility impaired individuals, medic alert, hearing
impaired individuals, and the elderly; thus, becoming companion, therapy and
service dogs [10]. The Paws and Stripes College program study revealed the
positive impact on inmate increased knowledge and skills in animal training, leading
participating inmates to better communication, conflict resolution, and
interpersonal behaviors which ultimately has the capacity to enhance future
employability. Homeless canines benefited by finding valued homes to care for
them while providing a useful service to families and those with special needs.
The community benefits from improvements in inmate behaviour while incarcerated
and their productivity in society once released thus, creating the potential to
forever change the lives of the inmates [11-13].
The author has no relevant
affiliations or financial involvement with a financial interest in or financial with the subject matter or
materials discussed in the manuscript.
There is no
conflict of interest.