Article Type : Research Article
Authors : Ahmed M, Siddique MA, Islam MM, Alam A, Nuruzzaman M and Roy D
Keywords : Tonsillectomy; Otolaryngologists; Hemorrhage; Bleeding
Background: Tonsillectomy is one of the surgical techniques most practiced by otolaryngologists, and despite being a relatively simple technique; it presents a considerable percentage of complications, such as postoperative bleeding. Objectives: The aim of the study was to compare the tonsillectomy in adults: indications and complications in a tertiary care hospital. Methods: This cross-sectional study was carried out in the Department of Medicine, Mymensingh medical college hospital, Mymensingh, during January 2023 to December 2023. A total of 200 patients were participated in the study. Statistical analyses of the results were be obtained by using window-based Microsoft Excel and Statistical Packages for Social Sciences (SPSS-24). Results: In this study, the population consisted of (56.5%) children under the age of 15 and (43.5%) adults over the age of 15. In terms of gender distribution, (54%) of the sample population was male, while (46%) was female. And 9(4.5%) of the patients suffered trauma, 5(2.5%) had difficult intubation, 3(1.5%) had anesthesia difficulty, and 183(0.91) had no complications. In terms of the study population's symptoms, 113 (56.5%) had recurrent or chronic tonsillitis with obstructive symptoms and 34 (22%) had adenotonsillar hypertrophy with obstructive symptoms. Conclusion: The most common surgical indication was recurrent tonsillitis and bleeding the most common and important complication. Regarding the risk of post-tonsillectomy hemorrhage, no statistically significant differences were detected in patients in whom tonsillar pillars were sutured comparing to those that were not, nor related to surgical indication. Tonsillectomy was not set as outpatient surgery at the time
Tonsillectomy is a common procedure in the otolaryngology practice. Despite the rising number of tonsillectomies performed as an ambulatory operation, the safety of this procedure in our context has yet to be established. Because of the complications, some hospitals still do it as an in-patient treatment. Strict criteria must be followed and carefully audited if any center decides to convert to an outpatient setting [1,2]. The most common and significant complication of tonsillectomy is post-tonsillectomy hemorrhage (PTH). In general, original PTH is considered more prevalent and dangerous than secondary hemorrhage [3]. Primary bleeding is thought to be caused by surgical technique, but subsequent hemorrhage is caused by eschar sloughing, trauma from solid meal consumption, tonsillar bed infection, post-operative nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) use, or idiopathic causes [4]. Other major complications of tonsillectomy include respiratory compromise [5]. Other minor problems of tonsillectomy include fever, nausea, vomiting, and poor oral intake, which can progress to a more serious condition if dehydration occurs [5]. In view of the complications, each institution must establish its own safety guidelines for doing ambulatory tonsillectomy, as certain patients may require hospitalization owing to medical contraindications or social reasons. Patients with severe asthma who are taking regular medications, diabetes, coagulation disorders, hypersomnia or sleep apnea syndrome, sickle cell disease, epilepsy, and other diseases that were previously thought to necessitate an overnight stay may be ineligible for ambulatory tonsillectomy [6]. Tonsillectomy is a surgical surgery that removes a tonsil or tonsils. It is one of the most popular surgical procedures in otolaryngology practice [7]. Postoperative discomfort and post-tonsillectomy hemorrhage (PTH) are two major concerns following surgery. Common risk factors for PTH include old age, chronic tonsillitis, significant intraoperative blood loss, and high postoperative mean arterial pressure [8]. Tonsillectomy can result in a wide range of complications, including blood-tinged mucus and potentially fatal hemorrhage. [9] Clinical practice guidelines require that all institutions conducting tonsillectomy conduct an audit on PTH to compare with national and worldwide rates [10]. The most common rationale for tonsillectomy in adults is chronic recurrent tonsillitis, which causes frequent fever and a debilitating painful throat. Tonsillectomy is one of the most common operations performed by an ENT surgeon. Usually, the treatment is performed as an inpatient surgery. With the growing desire to reduce healthcare expenses, free up hospital beds, and decrease elective surgery waiting lists, tonsillectomy is increasingly being performed on a day-care basis.
Methodology
This
cross-sectional study was carried out in the Department of Medicine, Mymensingh
medical college hospital, Mymensingh, during January 2023 to December 2023. A
total of 200 patients were participated in the study and both patients were
male and female. After taking consent and matching eligibility criteria, data
were collected from patients on variables of interest using the predesigned
structured questionnaire by interview, observation. Statistical analyses of the
results were be obtained by using window-based Microsoft Excel and Statistical
Packages for Social Sciences (SPSS-24).
Results
(Table 1) shows age distribution of the study population, it was observed that 113(56.5%) children were belonged to age ?15years and 87(43.5%) adults were belonged to age ?15 years. (Figure 1) shows sex distribution of the study population, it was observed that majority 108(54%) patients were male and 92(46%) patients were female. (Table 2) shows socio-economic status of the study population, it was observed that 62(31%) of the patients come from low class, 86(43%) of the patients come from middle class and 52(26%) of the patients come from high class family respectively. (Table 3) shows Intra-operative complications of the study population, it was observed that 9(4.5%) of the patients were in trauma, 5(2.5%) had difficult intubation, 3(1.5%) patients had Anesthetic complication and 183(0.91) patients had no complication respectively.
(Table
4) shows post-operative complications of the study population, it was observed
that 7(3.5%) of the patients had primary hemorrhage, 7(3.5%) had secondary
hemorrhage, 4(2%) patients had infection and 174(0.91) patients had no
complication respectively. (Table 5) shows indications of symptoms of the study
population, it was observed that 113(56.5%) of the patients had recurrent or
chronic tonsillitis with obstructive symptoms, 49(29.5%) had recurrent or
chronic tonsillitis without obstructive symptoms, 34(22%) patients had
adenotonsillar hypertrophy with obstructive symptoms respectively. (Table 6)
shows the duration of symptoms of the study population, it was observed that
3(1.5%) of the patients were ?3 months, 6(3%) of the patients were >6 months
and <1-year months and 177(88.5%) were ?1 year respectively.
Discussion
This
cross-sectional study was carried out in the Medicine, Mymensingh medical
college hospital, Mymensingh. During 1 year of study period, total 200 samples
were included in this study. Tonsillectomy is a common surgical treatment
performed by otolaryngologists on pediatric and adult patients. This is a
commonly done operation in the pediatric age group. It is suggested for those
who have recurrent tonsillitis and require frequent medical treatment.
Tonsillectomy lowers medicine consumption due to frequent sore throats and
fevers. There is limited research on patient-reported outcomes in adult
tonsillectomy. In this study it was observed that, the study population
consisted of 113 (56.5%) children under the age of 15 and 87 (43.5%) adults over
the age of 15. In terms of gender distribution, 108 (54%) of the sample
population was male, while 92 (46%) was female. According to the socioeconomic
position of the study population, 62(31%) of the patients are from the low
class, 86(43%) are from the middle class, and 52(26%) are from the high class.
Tonsillectomy is one of the most common surgical operations in the United
States, with over 530,000 performed each year in children under the age of 15
[11]. Numerous research have been conducted to investigate the indications and
consequences of juvenile tonsillectomy. Historically, the most common reason
for tonsillectomy in children was recurrent/chronic tonsillitis; however, as
antibiotic use increased, the reason for surgery moved to the treatment of
upper airway congestion [11]. Unlike in pediatrics, the most prevalent
indication for tonsillectomy in adults is recurrent/chronic tonsillitis, which
may be owing to greater drug failure rates due to resistant bacteria [12].
Other reasons for tonsillectomy in adults include upper airway obstruction
resulting in obstructive sleep apnea (OSA), suspected or proven malignancy, and
tonsil-related symptoms as halitosis, dysphagia, tonsillar stones, and
persistent sore throat [13]. Studies that examined the medical and economic
benefits of tonsillectomy in adults found that it enhanced quality of life by
reducing antibiotic use, physician visits, sore throat episodes, and missed
work days [14]. In this current study, the study population, 9(4.5%) of the
patients suffered trauma, 5(2.5%) had difficult intubation, 3(1.5%) had
anesthesia difficulty, and 183(0.91) had no complication. In terms of
post-operative complications in the study population, 7 (3.5%) had original
bleeding, 7 (3.5%) had secondary hemorrhage, 4 (2%) had infection, and 174
(0.91) had no complications. Low socioeconomic level has also been identified
as a risk factor for return, as indicated by numerous research, potentially due
to increased severity of obstructive sleep apnea and recurrent tonsillitis
[15]. These unsuccessful treatments in low socioeconomic groups may be
exacerbated by challenges to effective physician-patient communication, patient
education and understanding, and provider bias [16]. Finally, residing in
regional Victoria reduced the likelihood of hospital visits (relative to
metropolitan Victoria). This could be owing to the limited quantity and
geographic accessibility of hospitals in remote locations, where patients are
instead referred to a general practitioner. The study revealed that, in terms of the
study population's symptoms, 113 (56.5%) had recurrent or chronic tonsillitis
with obstructive symptoms, 49 (29.5%) had recurrent or chronic tonsillitis
without obstructive symptoms, and 34 (22%) had adenotonsillar hypertrophy with
obstructive symptoms. Despite
the potentially life-threatening complication of bleeding, the tonsillectomy
technique has been demonstrated to be safe as an outpatient procedure in a
number of trials, with overall complication rates ranging from 0.37% to 4.1% [17,18].
Many other research focused exclusively on post-operative problems, therefore
the overall proportion of intra-operative complications in different contexts
is rather arbitrary [19]. In our analysis, only 3.7% of intraoperative problems
were observed. There was no intraoperative bleeding that required a
transfusion, and only 2.6% of cases of minor trauma were reported. Similar to
intra-operative complications, very minor percentages of post-operative
complications were observed. Primary and secondary bleeding were the highest
complication rates (1.9% each). Post-tonsillectomy
hemorrhage (PTH), which includes both primary and secondary PTH, has been
utilized in numerous studies to predict the safety of ambulatory tonsillectomy
two studies conducted in India and Singapore that concluded the safety of
tonsillectomy procedures found 1.95% and 7.7% of PTH occurrence, respectively,
and our results were well within this range. Another patient experienced
bleeding at 9 hours post-operatively, but no surgical intervention was required
to manage it. Meanwhile, secondary bleeding in our investigation occurred
between days 4 and 11 post-operatively, which is consistent with the prior
study's stated average length. [17]. In our present study, the study found that
3(1.5%) patients had symptoms for less than 3 months, 6 (3.3%) patients had
symptoms for more than 6 months but less than a year, and 177 (88.5%) patients
had symptoms for more than a year. The reasons for tonsillectomy have
changed throughout history. In the pre-antibiotic period, tonsillectomy was
regarded as a highly efficient therapeutic treatment for both the cure and
prevention of tonsil infection problems, with 1.4 million tonsillectomies
performed in the United States alone in 1949 [18]. This trend lasted until the
1970s, when indications began to be questioned, resulting in a significant
decrease in the number of tonsillectomies performed annually: from over 2
million in the 1960s to 400,000 now in the United States [19]. The Spanish
Society of Otorhinolaryngology currently recommends tonsillectomy for tonsillar
malignancy, significant oropharyngeal blockage due to tonsillar hypertrophy,
and chronic tonsillar bleeding. Recurrent acute tonsillitis, chronic
tonsillitis, and peritonsillar abscess or phlegmon are all related signs.
Limitations of the Study
The
present study was conducted in a very short period due to time constraints and
funding limitations. The small sample size was also a limitation of the present
study.
Conclusion
Tonsillectomy
in adults is most often indicated for chronic infections, peritonsillar
abscesses, or osa. Although the procedure carries higher risks in adults than
in children, with proper surgical technique and postoperative care,
complications such as hemorrhage, pain, and infection can be minimized.
Managing pain and maintaining hydration are key components of recovery.
Recommendation
This
study can serve as a pilot to much larger research involving multiple centres
that can provide a nationwide picture, validate regression models proposed in
this study for future use and emphasize points to ensure better management and
adherence.
Acknowledgements
The
wide range of disciplines involved in the tonsillectomy in adults: indications
and complications in tertiary care hospital research means that editors need
much assistance from references in the evaluation of papers submitted for
publication. I would also like to be grateful to my colleagues and family who
supported me and offered deep insight into the study.