Article Type : Research Article
Authors : Mtibaa L, Ghorbel S, Ferchichi S, Boutheina J and Halwani C
Keywords : Necrotizing otitis externa; Diabetes mellitus; Microbiology
Objectives: Necrotizing otitis externa (NOE) is a
life-threatening infection of the external auditory canal that can extend to
the skull base, predominantly affecting diabetic and immunocompromised
patients. This study aimed to describe the clinical characteristics,
microbiological profile, and management of NOE in order to improve patient
outcomes.
Methods: We conducted a retrospective study over a
5-year period in the ENT and cervicofacial surgery department of the Military
Hospital of Tunis. All patients diagnosed and treated for NOE were included.
Demographic data, clinical presentation, microbiological findings, therapeutic
management, and outcomes were analyzed.
Results: A total of 39 patients (40 affected ears)
were included, with a mean age of 71 years and a male-to-female ratio of 1.29.
All patients had diabetes mellitus. The mean delay before consultation was 50
days. Otalgia was the predominant symptom, and facial nerve palsy was observed
in 8% of cases. Microbiological cultures were positive in 43% of cases. Among
bacterial isolates, Pseudomonas aeruginosa accounted for 53%, with a resistance
rate of 22%. Fungal pathogens were identified in 37% of cases, predominantly
Aspergillus flavus. Empirical antipseudomonal antibiotic therapy was initiated
in 59% of patients and administered to all cases, while antifungal treatment
was prescribed in 51% based on microbiological results. Overall, infections
were classified as bacterial (50%), fungal (33%), and mixed (18%).
Conclusion: Clinical outcomes were favorable, with no
relapses or mortality reported. These findings emphasize the emerging role of
fungal pathogens and antimicrobial resistance, highlighting the need for
standardized therapeutic algorithms in the management of NOE.
Necrotizing
otitis externa (NOE), formerly known as malignant otitis externa [1], is a
severe infection of the external auditory canal that may extend to the skull
base, leading to osteomyelitis [2,3]. It predominantly affects
immunocompromised patients, particularly those with diabetes mellitus, and is
most commonly caused by Pseudomonas aeruginosa [3]. Diagnosis remains
challenging, as standardized diagnostic criteria have only recently been
established [4,5]. This diagnostic uncertainty may delay treatment initiation
and complicate management. Without prompt and appropriate therapy, NOE can
result in cranial nerve involvement, intracranial extension, and even death
[6]. Management relies on prolonged antipseudomonal antibiotic therapy combined
with meticulous local care of the external auditory canal. Advances in
antimicrobial therapy have significantly improved prognosis, reducing mortality
from approximately 50% to less than 5%. However, the emergence of resistant
bacterial strains and the increasing recognition of fungal NOE represent
growing challenges, complicating therapeutic decision-making. The aim of this
study was to describe the clinical presentation, microbiological profile, and
therapeutic management of NOE in our cohort.
We
conducted a retrospective descriptive study of patients treated for necrotizing
otitis externa in the Department of Otolaryngology and Cervicofacial Surgery at
the Main Military Teaching Hospital of Tunis between January 2018 and December
2022. All included patients had a confirmed diagnosis of NOE based on clinical
presentation and imaging findings and were hospitalized in our department for
management. Patients with severe but non-necrotizing otitis externa without
osteitic involvement, otitis media extending to the external auditory canal,
neoplastic or inflammatory pathologies of the external auditory canal or middle
ear, as well as patients with incomplete or unusable medical records, were
excluded. Data were collected retrospectively from medical records and included
demographic characteristics, comorbidities, clinical features, laboratory and
microbiological findings, imaging results, therapeutic modalities, and
follow-up outcomes. The study protocol was approved by the Institutional Review
Board of the Military Hospital of Tunis. As this was a retrospective study
using anonymized medical records, the requirement for written informed consent
was waived.
Patient Demographics
and Comorbidities
A
total of 39 patients (40 ears) were included. The mean age was 71 years (range
43–92), and 84% were over 60. There was a slight male predominance (M/F ratio
1.29). All patients had diabetes mellitus, predominantly type 2 (97%). Poor
glycemic control was observed in 47%, and 27% had diabetes-related
complications. Other comorbidities included: Hypertension (56%), coronary
artery disease (38%), and dyslipidemia (21%).
Premedication
with oral antibiotics was reported in 23 patients (59%), mostly
amoxicillin–clavulanic acid alone or combined with ciprofloxacin, which may
have contributed to diagnostic delay. The mean interval from symptom onset to
hospital admission was 50 days (median 30).
Clinical Presentation
On otoscopy:
Microbiological
Findings
Based
on combined microbiological and clinical data, infections were classified as
bacterial in 20 cases (50%), fungal in 13 cases (33%), and mixed
bacterial–fungal in 7 cases (18%).
Bacterial cultures
Initial bacterial cultures were positive in 16 patients (17 ears, 43%). The most frequently isolated bacteria were:
Antibiotic
resistance was observed in 22% of bacterial isolates, without a clear
association with prior antibiotic therapy.
Fungal cultures
Fungal cultures were positive in 13 patients (37%), yielding 16 isolates. The distribution of fungal pathogens was as follows:
Mixed fungal infections were identified in three patients, including:
Imaging and Paraclinical Investigations
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was performed in 8 patients. Abnormalities included:
Bone
scintigraphy was performed in 25 patients and was positive in all, consistent
with active osteitis.
Local and systemic
therapy
All patients received daily care of the external auditory canal (EAC), and canal calibration was performed in 38 cases, with granulation tissue debridement performed as indicated. Histological examination of tissue samples revealed inflammatory changes, and one biopsy was obtained under general anesthesia for microbiological analysis. Systemic antibiotic therapy was administered to all patients, with the most commonly used regimen being ciprofloxacin–ceftazidime (n=35). Among these, 14 patients received culture-guided therapy, while 21 were treated empirically (Table 1). The mean duration of antibiotic therapy was 62 days (range 16–>90 days). Alternative regimens were required in five patients due to resistance or poor clinical response (Table 1). Antifungal therapy was administered to 20 patients (51%) based on positive fungal cultures (Table 2). Voriconazole was used in 13 patients and fluconazole in 7. One patient was switched from amphotericin B to voriconazole due to renal toxicity. The duration of antifungal therapy ranged from three to four months. Analgesics were provided to all patients, with 12% requiring level II opioids for pain control. Corticosteroids were administered in two patients with facial palsy. Four patients with venous thrombosis received anticoagulation therapy, all with favorable outcomes.
Adjunctive therapy
Hyperbaric
oxygen therapy (HBOT) was administered in 10 patients (26%), with 9–28 sessions
(mean 16). Indications included poor response to antibiotics and neurological
involvement, particularly facial palsy. No patients required surgical
intervention.
Pseudomonas
aeruginosa remains the predominant pathogen in necrotizing
otitis externa (NOE), identified in 53% of our patients, followed by
coagulase-negative Staphylococcus (29%), consistent with previous reports
[3,6]. The observed 22% resistance rate of Pseudomonas aeruginosa to
ciprofloxacin underscores the need for early culture-guided therapy and
vigilance in antibiotic stewardship to prevent treatment failure [7,8]. Fungal
infections, particularly Aspergillus flavus and Candida albicans,
were observed in 50% of cases, frequently coexisting with bacterial pathogens.
The relatively high proportion of fungal isolates observed in our cohort
highlights the need for systematic mycological investigation in patients with
NOE, particularly in cases of poor response to antibacterial therapy.
Superficial cultures may underestimate fungal involvement, and deep tissue
biopsy remains the gold standard when systemic antifungal therapy is considered
[8-10]. Management of NOE remains complex and requires a multidisciplinary
approach. Early empiric antipseudomonal therapy, typically with dual
intravenous antibiotics, should be initiated promptly, followed by adjustments
according to culture results [6,8,11]. Ciprofloxacin is favored for its bone
penetration, though monotherapy is generally discouraged due to the risk of
resistance [9,12]. In our cohort, the mean treatment duration was eight weeks,
consistent with literature recommending at least six weeks, with extension in
cases of slow clinical response, cranial nerve involvement, or poor glycemic
control [12-14].
Systemic
antifungal therapy, mainly voriconazole, was administered in 51% of patients
based on microbiological evidence. Empirical antifungal therapy was avoided to
minimize toxicity, although delayed initiation may pose a risk in invasive
aspergillosis [8-10]. Optimal glycemic control and regular endocrinology
follow-up were essential adjuncts to therapy [7,8,13]. Surgical intervention
played a limited role and was reserved for refractory cases or complications;
none were required in our series. Hyperbaric oxygen therapy (HBOT) was
administered in 26% of patients with poor response or cranial nerve
involvement, reflecting the variable evidence for its benefit [15]. Our results
support a multidisciplinary approach combining targeted antibiotics, antifungal
therapy when indicated, and strict glycemic control, which contributed to the
absence of relapses or mortality in this cohort. The study highlights several
key findings: a high prevalence of Pseudomonas aeruginosa, frequent
fungal involvement, and effective multidisciplinary management resulting in
favorable outcomes. Strengths include comprehensive clinical, microbiological,
and imaging data, as well as consistent follow-up enabling reliable assessment
of treatment response. Limitations include the retrospective single-center
design, small sample size, and partial use of advanced imaging such as 18F-FDG
PET, which may have influenced the evaluation of healing. Assessment of healing
relied on clinical and laboratory improvement, supported by nuclear imaging when
indicated. No recurrences or deaths were observed, consistent with improved
outcomes reported in recent literature [8]. Overall, these results support a
standardized, multidisciplinary protocol combining early targeted antibiotics,
antifungal therapy when indicated, glycemic control, and selective adjunctive
interventions to optimize outcomes, reduce hospitalization, and minimize
complications in NOE.
Necrotizing otitis externa remains a challenging infection that requires early diagnosis and a multidisciplinary approach. Our findings underscore the importance of systematic microbiological investigation, including fungal cultures, to guide targeted therapy. Based on our experience, we propose the structured management protocol presented in Figure 2. This strategy, emphasizing rapid adaptation and individualized treatment, provides a practical framework to improve patient outcomes, reduce relapse rates, and optimize antimicrobial stewardship in NOE.
Figure 1: CT scan centered on the left petrous bone, axial view with bone window, showing extensive bony lysis of the external auditory canal walls (red arrows), with extension to the mandibular fossa of the temporal bone and the ipsilateral mandibular condyle (blue arrows).
Figure
2: Proposed management algorithm of NOE.
Standardized
diagnostic and therapeutic protocols are crucial to optimize management and
reduce complications in NOE.