Article Type : Review Article
Authors : Méndez J and Villasanti U
Keywords : Green tea; Camellia sinensis; Mouthwash
Study Background: In the case of reducing dental plaque, a green tea mouthwash has been studied alone or combined with other natural agents. Aim: To evaluate the effect of green tea used as a mouthwash for reducing dental plaque, gingivitis and halitosis.
Methods: Cochrane database clinical trials published from 2010 to 2020 were reviewed. Studies that met the inclusion criteria were reviewed by 2 authors individually. A qualitative review of the data was performed.
Results: Eight studies were included in the systematic review. There was no difference between green tea alone against chlorhexidine. But there were better results when combining green tea with xylitol or Salvadora persica L. extract.
Conclusion: Green tea mouthwash may be a viable natural mouthwash and can give better results when combining with other agents.
Mouth rinses are extensively promoted in prevention of dental caries. The significance of mouth and teeth cleanliness has been recorded from the ancient days of civilization to the 21st century [1]. In recent years, antimicrobial properties of medicinal plants are being increasingly reported from different parts of the world [2]. People all around the world are turning towards use of natural extracts such as herbal products for both prophylaxis and treatment of different diseases. Generally, three types of tea including black tea, green tea and Oolong tea (a Chinese type of tea) are derived from a shrub named Camellia sinensis. Green tea has advantage to other types of tea because it is less influenced by the fermentation process and its compositions remain stable [3].
Considering this, there has been a growing interest in using herbal agents as green tea as mouthwash. Green tea have shown to have anti-inflammatory properties along antibacterial and other properties [4]. This effect could be mainly attributed to the antibacterial activities of green tea catechins and other components such as caffeic acid, quercetin, chlorogenic acid, gallic acid, myricetin, kaempferol [5]. Green tea has been studied alone or combined with other natural herbs. This review has the objective to determine the effect of green tea as a natural mouthwash for reducing dental plaque, gingivitis and halitosis.
The Cochrane databases were reviewed. Clinical trials published between the years 2016 to 2020 were reviewed. The key words used were: green tea, mouthwash. Studies that met the inclusion criteria (Randomized controlled trials, in vivo studies) were reviewed by 2 authors individually. (Studies that did not meet methodological quality were excluded). The studies that fulfilled the inclusion criteria were processed for the extraction of data. The data were as follows: the name of first author, year of publication, age of patients, length of study, intervention techniques and clinical results. A qualitative review of the data was performed.
The flow diagram of study selection is shown in Figure 1. Of total of 47 studies identified through the search in the databases, 8 were included for the systematic review. There was no difference between green tea alone against chlorhexidine. But there were better results when combining green tea with xylitol or Salvadora persica L. extract (Table 1).
Table 1: Green tea clinical trials study characteristics (n=8).
First Author |
Year of publication |
Age of patients |
Length of study |
Intervention
techniques |
Clinical results |
|
1 |
Rassameemasmaung S |
2013 |
18 to 55 |
4 weeks |
Intervention: The
green tea. Placebo: was a hydroalcoholic brownie solution. |
No differences between
groups |
2 |
Deshpande |
2018 |
10 to 14 |
1 month |
Intervention 1: grean
tea Intervention. 2: green tea plus ginger mouthrinse. Comparator:
chlorhexidine |
No differences between
groups |
3 |
Asawa |
2017 |
18 to 25 |
1 month |
Intervention1: Green Tea.
Placebo: Chlorhexidine |
No differences between
groups |
4 |
Hajiahmadi M |
2019 |
6 to 12 |
2 weeks |
Interventioon 1: 5%
"green tea". Intervention 2: 20%
"green tea with xylitol". |
"green tea with
xylitol" mouthwash is significantly better on reducing salivary
colonies |
5 |
Abdulbaqi HR |
2016 |
25 to 40 |
24 hours |
Intervention 1: green
tea and Salvadora persica L. Intervention 2: Chlorexidine. Placebo: Dystilled
water |
The
test mouthwash significantly reduced plaque accumulation when
compared with placebo and
chlorhexidine mouthwashes. |
6 |
Sarin S |
2015 |
18 to 60 |
28 days |
Intervention: green tea.
Placebo: dystilled water |
There was a
significant (p < 0.05) reduction in mean GI and PI scores among the test
group |
7 |
Radafshar G |
2017 |
18 to 40 |
4 weeks |
Intervention1: Green Tea.
Placebo: Chlorhexidine. |
No differences between
groups |
8 |
Hegde RJ |
2017 |
8 to 12 |
2 weeks |
Intervention1: Chlorhexidine.
Intervention 2: Green Tea. Placebo: combination mouth rinse |
No differences between
groups |
Figure 1: Flow diagram of the study selection.
The results of this review show that green tea mouthwash can be considered as an alternative to chlorhexidine and combined with other agents can give better results [6-13].
This make sense since green tea is reported to be very rich in fluoride and catechin, a bioactive component, which exerts an anti-cariogenic effect by inhibiting the proliferation of the streptococcal agent, interfering with the process of bacterial adhesion to tooth enamel and also by inhibiting glucosyltransferase [14].
Chlorhexidine and green tea mouthwashes found to be effective in reducing plaque index and it has been shown to be equally effective in gingivitis reduction [15]. Same as other study that concluded that the use of green tea and chlorhexidine mouthwashes has a similar effect on bacterial colonies in the pharynx [16].
The results from the meta-analysis indicated that there was no significant difference between chlorhexidine and green tea, either at endpoint or over time. In addition, there was little evidence of side effects with green tea mouthwash [17]. However, other study suggested found that green tea as a mouthwash is more effective compared to chlorhexidine mouthwash and is an appropriate
adjunctive measure in the treatment of chronic periodontitis [18]. On the other side other studies conclude that Chlorhexidine found to be superior to 5% green tea in reducing bacterial load in aerosol samples [19]. Even though only one database (Cochrane) was searched in this review, this database has the better quality in clinical trials so the results can be considered feasible.
Green tea mouthwash may be a viable natural mouthwash and can give better results when combining with other agents.