Article Type : Research Article
Authors : Treasure Njoku-obi
Keywords : Microbial examination, Automated teller machine Owerri
This
study assessed the microbial examination of Automated Teller Machine (ATM) in
Owerri, Imo state. A total of five ATMs were selected from different locations
within Owerri Municipal, Imo state was used for this study. Samples were
collected from the key-pads and screens of the ATM devices outside banking
hails with sterile cotton swabs soaked in physiologic saline. The swab stick
was removed in an aseptic manner and corked properly immediately. These were
transported to the laboratory inside a sealed plastic bag within 2 hours of collection. The results show the total
heterotrophic bacteria county of ranged from 2.2'x 102 cfu/g - 2.9 x
102 cfu/g, the coliform bacterial counts ranged from 2.0 x 102
cfu/g - 3.1 x 102 cfu/g and total fungal count ranged from 1.1 x 102
cfu/g- 2.3 x 102 cfu/g. Bacterial isolated were Escheriches coli, Pseudoatomic
specie., Klebsiella specie, and Staphylococcus aiireus. Prevenance of isolation
of bacterial isolates shows that Staphylococcus specie [15(34.8)] were the
prevalent isolates, followed by E. coli [10 (23.2)], Pseudomonas specie [9(20.9)] and KlebsieUa specie
[9(20.9)]. A total of four fungi were
isolated. These comprises of Aspergillus
specie., Rhizopus specie, Penicillin specie, and Candida specie This study has
revealed the presence of bacterial contamination on ATM keypads, with possible
health challenges. The organisms isolated were Staphylococcus aureus,
Escherichia coll, KlebsieUa specie, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Asterius specie.,
Rhizopus specie, Penicillin specie, and Candida specie. Tf pathogens can be
found on ATM keypads, it is easier to comprehend why there are enrphases on
public health safety.
Contamination
of environmental objects and surfaces by microorganisms is a common phenomenon.
The presence of viable pathogenic bacteria on inanimate objects has been
reported by earlier researchers [1]. Several studies of the human environment
have demonstrated contamination and coloration of inanimate objects such as
door handles, plastics, faucets, phones, money, fabrics, plastics and other
fomiles by bacteria which is also responsible for the spread of various
bacterial infections [2]. Human hands have been shown to play a significant
role in the transmission and cross contamination of microorganisms between
environmental surfaces [3]. Furthermore, microorganisms found to contaminate of
mites have been shown to persist on the surfaces for periods ranging from a few
hours to several months, and have been detected and recovered from surfaces
after routine conventional cleaning. The ability of inanimate objects to
support viable microorganisms for a prolonged period of time is well documented
[4] and such environmental surfaces and objects, especially those in close
proximity with persons and frequently touched, poses a lot of threat to human
health and is a cause for public concern. Examples of such inanimate objects in
the environment that are currently in frequent contact with the hands are the
keypads of an automated teller machine (ATM). Automatic teller machines (ATMs),
also known as cash machines in the United States are the longest standing and
most widely used form of computer driven public technology [5], with an
estimated over 2.4 million units in use since their invention and use in the
late 1960's, This wide usage has consequently led to regular and unrestricted
sharing of interfaces among users. With the harboring of microorganisms
acquired -from the human microflora or as transient organisms from the
environment, and previous accounts of cross contamination of microorganisms
[6]. it is readily conceivable that pathogens could be transferred among users
who share interfaces.
Sample area
Imo State is one of the 36 States of Nigeria, located in the southeast region of the country. Formed in 1976 when it split from the former Fast-Central State, Imo Slate is bordered by Abia Slate on the east, Delta Stale to the West, Anambra State on the north, and Rivers State to the south. The state capital, Owerri, is often described as the entertainment capital of Nigeria. Imo State is a predominantly Igbo speaking state, with Igbo people consenting an estimated 98% of the stales population. During the Nigerian Civil War (1967-1970), the present-day borders of Imo State were part of the Republic of Riafra, a secessionist state formed by Igbo nationalists. Secessionist sentiment remains commonplace in modern Imo State, with the Movement for the Actualization of the Sovereign State of Biafra (MASSOB) being headquartered in the district: of Okigwe
Sample Size
A total of live ATMs was selected from different locations in Imo State
Ethical Approval
Written permission was obtained from five (5) banking organizations including Zenith, United Bank of Africa, "First Bank of Nigeria, Access Bank and Stanbic Bank.
Eligibility of Subject
Inclusion Criteria
Samples were collected from the key-pads and screens of the ATM devices outside banking halls with sterile cotton swabs soaked in physiologic saline. The swab stick was removed in an aseptic manner and corked properly immediately. These were transported to the laboratory inside a sealed plastic bag within 2 hours of collection. All samples were transported to the laboratory as soon as possible without delay and was processed on the same clay of collection.
Media preparation
All
the media used were prepared according to the manufacturer's guide. Mannitol
Salt Agar (MSA), MaeConkey and Nutrient, agar plates were used for the
isolation of bacteria and saboraud dextrose agar was used for isolation of
fungi.
Identification of The Bacteria Isolates
Identification of pure colonies using morphological characteristics were based on morphological differences, colonies was isolated from their axenic culture. Petri-d is lies was divided into quadrants and sub culturing carried out by streaking. Colony morphology observations formed a major identifying criterion for bacteria. The characteristics observed include (circular, irregular, spreading), elevation (flat, slightly raised or markedly raised), pigmentation (red, white, pink, colorless), size (pinpoint, small, medium, large) and texture.
Gram Staining
Culture plates of bacteria, microscopes, wire loops, normal saline, Bunsen burners, timers, microscope slides, oil immersion, distilled water, crystal violet, and Ingol iodine. On a clean slide, a drop of sterile saline was added using a sterilized wire loop. The wire loop was flamed to red hot and allowed to cool, and then, a small number of cells from an isolated colony 24 hours on a culture plate was collected and mixed in a drop of saline and it was spread on the slide to make a thin, uniform smear. The smear was then allowed to air dry before they heal lead by carefully passing them over a Bunsen Burner flame six to eight times. Crystal violet was used to stain the smear for one minute, then it washed off with distilled water and drained, then it LugoPs iodine was added and was left on the smear for 1 minute, which was washed off gently with distilled water and drained. The slides were decolorized with acetone for 3 seconds by adding uniformly and quickly to the slide, it was washed off quickly with distilled water and then saffranin was added and after 1 minute it was washed off with distilled water. The slides were air dried and immersion oil was dropped on the smears and examined microscopically using x100 oil immersion objective of the microscope.
Identification of Bacteria Using Biochemical Methods
Indole Test
Kovac's
reagent, peptone water, incubator, wire loop. The test organism was inoculated in
sterilized tube containing peptone water broth, the solution was incubated
aseptically at 37°C for 24-28 hours, then 0.5ml of Kovac's reagent was added to
the broth. The result: was noted.
Methyl Red Test
MR.-VP
medium (glucose broth), methyl red indicator, wire loop, incubator. By using a
sterile wire loop, (The test organism was inoculated into the fresh, sterile
prepared MR-VP medium and it was incubated at 37°C for 2-5 days. After
incubation the broth was obtained from the incubator, 5 drops of 0.04% solution
of alcoholic methyl red solution were added and mixed properly. Then the result
was read and rioted,
Voges- Proskauer Test
MR-VP broth, alpha naphthol, 40% KOH, deionized water. A tube containing the MR/VP broth was inoculated with the pure culture of (he tests organism and was incubated at 35°C at 24 hours. Then 1.5mL of 5% alpha naphthol and 0.5mL of 40% KOH was added and mixed properly. The bottles were left to stand for 5 minutes for aeration. Changes were observed.
Oxidase Test
Oxidase
reagent, bacterial cultures, Whatman No 2 filter paper, glass rod. A piece of
filter paper was placed in a clean Petri-dish and 2-3 drops of freshly prepared
oxidase reagents was added. Using a
sterile loop, test bacterial was picked and smeared over a small area of the
filler paper. The color change was examined after 10 seconds.
Catalase Test
Bacterial
culture, H202, glass slide, test tubes, glass rod. A drop of 3% H202 was placed
on the opposite ends of a clean grease free glass slide with the help of a
dropper. A small portion of (her bacterial culture was transferred on the glass
slide containing the H2O2 with a sterile glass rod. The sample was examined for
immediate bubbling effervescence of 02.
Identification of Fungi
Isolates
The
growth pattern, pigmentation and size of colonies were recorded at the
incubation period to aid identification of the organisms.
Use Slide Culture Method
The
isolate was identified using cultural characteristics and morphology. With the
help of sterile petri dishes, sterile filter paper was placed in each of the
Petri dishes and 1ml of distilled water was added into the petri dish as
sterile U shape glass rod was placed in each of the petri dish. Will) the help
of inoculating needle, a cubelike shape of already prepared SDA was cut, four
days to 1-week fungal growth was smeared by the four sides of the SDA using a
sterile wire loop and a sterile cover slip was placed on the inoculums in the
Petri dish. The plate was then covered and kept at room temperature for 4 to
7days as growth was observed daily before examination.
Cell Morphology of Fungi
Isolate
A
drop of lactophenol (LP) was placed on a clean microscopic slide The cover slip
from the glass culture was gently removed and placed in the drop of lactophenol
(LP) and also a drop of LP was dropped on the slide from the old culture as the
media cultured on the slide was gently removed a sterile cover slip was placed
on the slide and observe microscopically. It was first view at X10 to focus the
lens well then X40 to get a clearer view.
Results
Table
1 shows the bacterial counts of each sample. The total heterotrophic bacteria
count of ranged from 2.2 x 102 cfu/g -2.9 x 102"
cfu/g, the coliform bacterial counts ranged from 2.0 x 102 cfu/g
-3.1 x 102 cfu/g and total fungal count ranged from 1.1 x 102 cfu/g
-2.3 x 102" cfu/g.
Table 1: Total Viable Consult of Bacteria Isolates.
|
Total Viable Count (CFU/g) |
||||
|
SN |
Sample |
THC |
TCC |
TFC |
|
1 2 3 4 5 |
A B C D E |
2.2 x 102 2.6 x 102 2.9 x 102 2.8 x 102 2.4 x 102 |
2.8 x 102 2.5 x 102 3.0 x 102 2.0 x 102 3.1 x 102 |
1.1 x 102 2.0 x 102 1.8 x 102 1.6 x 102 2.3 x 102 |
|
S/N |
Morphology |
Gramstaining |
Catalase |
Citrate |
Indole |
Methylred |
Voges proskaeur |
Oxidase |
Motility |
Suspected organism |
|
1 |
Yellor, Glassy, Round, Coccie in cluster |
+ |
+ |
+ |
- |
+ |
+ |
+ |
- |
Staphylcococcus specie |
|
2 |
Greenish, Opague, Flat and Odour colony |
- |
+ |
+ |
- |
- |
- |
+ |
+ |
Pseudomonas
specie |
|
3 |
Cream, Smoot, Irregular, Short rod in
single colony |
- |
+ |
+ |
- |
- |
+ |
- |
- |
Klebsiella specie |
|
4 |
Cream, Smooth, Irregular, Short rod |
- |
+ |
- |
- |
+ |
- |
- |
- |
Escherichia coli |
Table 3: Prevalence of Isolation of Bacterial Pathogens.
|
Isolates |
Frequency (%) |
|
Escherichia
coli Staphylococcus
specie Pseudomonas
specie Klebsiella
specie Total |
10(23.2) 15 (34.8) 9 (20.9) 9(20.9) 43 (100.0) |
|
S/N |
|
Morphological characteristics |
Microscopie characteristics |
Probable organism
|
|
1 |
|
Compact, clusters of dark colony |
Hyline conidiophores phylides borne on vesicles,
clusters of dark walled conidia with spetate hyphae
|
Aspergillus
specie |
|
2 |
|
Cotton-like,
white in color |
Simple
and form apical, globular sporangia that are supported and elevated by a
column shapped columella
|
Rhizopus specie |
|
3 |
|
The pigmentation was initially white and became
green which later turned to pinkish with time. they were filamentous in
texture
|
Spetate hyphae with simple a conidiospores and
conidia were observed |
Penicillum
specie |
|
4 |
|
Creamy
colonies that are smooth, convex and with a yeasty odour |
Budding
spherical to elongated cells forming pesudmycelium |
Candida specie |
Table 5: Number and percentage of fungi species isolated from A.T.M.
|
Isolates |
Number of
Isolate |
Percentage |
|
Aspergillus specie Candida specie Pcniclllum specie
Rhizopus specie Total |
15 10 7 5 37 |
40.5% 27.0% 18.9% 13.5% 100% |
Keys
THBO
- Total Heterotrophic Bacteria count
TCC
=Total Coliform count
TSS
= Total Salmonella Shigella
Sample
A – Zenith bank
Sample
B = UIJA
Sample
C = First Bank of Nigeria
Sample
D = Access Bunk
Sample
E, - Stannic Bank
Morphological and Biochemical identification of bacteria isolates
Results from Table 2 shows the morphological appearances and biochemical properties of isolated bacteria. Bacterial isolated were Escherichia coli, Pseudomonas specie, Klebsiella specie, and Staphylococcus specie.
Prevalence of isolation
of bacterial pathogens
Table
3 shows the prevalence of isolation of bacterial isolates from A.T.M. Of the 43
bacterial isolates obtained, Staphylococcus specie [15(34.8] were the
prevalent: isolates, followed by K. coll ['10 (23.2)], Pscitcloinonas specie
[9(20.9) and Klebsiella specie [9(20.9)]
Colloidal and
Morphological features of the Fungi Isolates from A.T.M
Results
as shown in table 4 shows the Colonial and microscopic morphology of isolated
fungi associated with A.T.M. A total of four fungi were isolated. These
comprises of Aspcrgilins spiecie, Rhlzopns specie, Penicillin specie, and
Candida specie.
Number and percentage of
fungi species isolated from A.T.M
Table
5 shows the number and percentage of fungi species isolated from A.T'.M, which
revealed (hat Aspergillus sp. was the most common isolate ('-1-0.5%), followed
by Candida specie. (27.0%), Petucillum specie. (18,9%), and Rhizopus specie (1
3.5%).
ATM
machines are one of the most commonly touched surfaces today. The study
assessed the microbial contamination of shared surfaces on user hardware
interface of five (5) commercial banks randomly scattered within Owerri, Imo
state metropolis in south-east Nigeria. A total of 43 bacterial organisms
comprising of four (4) difference species were isolated. The result obtained in
(Table 2) showed that bacteria such as Staphylococcus aureus; Escherichia coli;
Klebsilla specie; and Pseudomonas aeruginosa, were isolated from the Automated
Teller Machine (ATM) located in Owerri, axis Imo State. This result is in
agreement with the result obtained by [7,8]. The bacteria isolated from (his
study can cause hand-to-mouth infections in man if hands are not sanitized after
using the ATM. There is also a possibility of them causing nosocomial
infections through medical personnel that used an ATM without thorough
sanitation of hands used on ATM in the hospital and its environs as also
reported by [9]. These findings are in agreement with the results obtained by
[10].
This
study has revealed the presence of bacterial contamination on ATM keypads, with
possible health. challenges. The organisms isolated were Staphylococcus aureus,
Escherichia coli, Klebsiella specie, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Aspergillus spp.,
Rhizopus specie, Penicillin specie, and Candida specie. If pathogens can be
found on ATM keypads, it is easier to comprehend why there are emphases on
public health safely. The need to combine technological innovation with safe
and healthy use is therefore strongly advocated in the light of current
findings. Therefore, this showcase a general responsibility to see that
measures are adequately place to ensure that transfer of infections through
ATMs is reduced to it barest minimum and if possible, it should be eradicated
totally.