Article Type : Review Article
Authors : Yu Edwin CL
Keywords : Autism spectrum disorder; Endowed labile body core; Rings on rings maladjustment; Core and match; Mental-physical causality; Developmental complexity
In ASDs, starting with genetic
vulnerabilities which may arise from adaptive mental edging changes on one
hand, and perturbed microbiota-gut-brain axis on the other hand, the prenatal
setup forms a body core that is in general labile and prone to both mental and
physical conditions with functional impairments. The internal processes and
external behavior of the brain and body in a self-organized system are mal-set
as developmental atypicalities with notable mood and disruptive behavior
problems in the neurodevelopmental domain. Modified neuronal networks since
early-life depend on the environment and energy/resources provision as well as
individual potential and self-regulatory setup for remodeling for emotive or
motive activities as these contribute to social engagement, cognitive, social,
and emotional growth. The postnatal makeup in ASD is altered during the stages
of development from both mental and physical impairments whereby a complexity
of atypicalities is developed. Layer upon layer, the rings on rings of
maladjustments impair matching capabilities, starting early with visuomotor
coordination impairment, suboptimal resource functioning, guarded food
selectivity, with related defensive behavior, atypical reward-seeking behavior,
and self-stimulatory drives depending on severity. More atypicalities may be
derived and evolve further with related guarded social behavior, altered
emotion-guided attention in ASD children that may evolve into emotion-evading
behaviors, and altered self-relevant reward system that dampens the rewarding
nature of social interaction and cognition. Depending on the degree of involvement,
this early setup from both mental and physical causality leads to the final ASD
symptom complex. This reemphasizes the consideration of physical functional
problems, which isolated consideration could have distracted past studies with
all along difficulties for finding pathogenesis of ASD. This paper describes
the whole problem where the parts aggregate into rings, when rings locked in
with another ring, to understand from the parts how they make up the whole
autistic spectrum.
The knowledge of the strong hereditary of autism is understood 20 years ago. Even not too long ago, progress in the genomics of non-syndromic autism spectrum disorder (nsASD) emphasized investigating rare, large effect, germline, heterozygous de novo coding mutations [1]. Yet after a lot of funded research, deleterious genes are now found surely not contributing to most of the patients. No definite resolute pathophysiology yet can be defined, and it has been exclaimed for “even in the historical present...., a whirlwind of ideas, movements, and positions has littered the autism literature [2].” A report in 2018 showed autistic spectrum disorders (ASD) may fully recover by early treatment [3]. Other modalities like bumetanide used to treat edema may also improve symptoms [4]. Large therapeutic margins may exist postnatally. The time will be changing with more awareness of postnatal ASD development from early presence of specific combinations of inherited neurobehavioral susceptibilities [5,6]. By reassembling topical findings, it is found that ASD reality stems from both mental and physical causality [7].
The genetic basis of ASD and its variable phenotypic presentation are complex. The strong heritability is contributed by common genetic variants [8,9] that brought about liabilities for common mental tendencies as well as developmental susceptibilities in individuals prone to ASD. These liabilities express with neurodevelopmental alterations related to a general vulnerability factor for different kinds of neurodevelopmental psychiatric disorders (NDPDs) [10,11]. Notably, such psychiatric disorders were more like each other in genetic profiles, in contrast to neurological disorders that in general markedly vary in genetic background [12,13]. It may be presumed that such neurobiological setup with these common genetic variants, common in human beings, provides a base conducive to development into diversity of phenotypes which by chance would furnish extraordinary abilities on one extreme, but on another end could also be associated with atypicalities often unacceptable in general population norms. These may be called mental edging labilities, resulting in developmental susceptibilities for NDPDs as well as adaptive phenotypic pliability [7]. An increased dose of deleterious effects of rare inherited, de novo, or somatic mutations contributes to the biased gene sets could also enhance the individual’s susceptibility to ASD [14]. Which developmental period these gene sets carrying the mental edging labilities are activated could be important. For schizophrenia, related genes are activated later, from infancy through adulthood [14]. For ASD, these are likely to occur prenatally, when early developmental “windows” open to the environment and during which important connections are formed. The pleiotropic loci are located within genes that express diversely in the brain, beginning in the second trimester prenatally, and together with a suite of neurodevelopmental processes, they regulate behavior formation throughout life [15]. The neurodevelopmental manifestations vary as they are subject to developmental molding of the body core and environmental incompatibilities at matching. Individuals affected with ASD may manifest ASD symptoms and impairments with phenotypic diversity. Lability in ASD affects both physical and mental makeup. The body having neurodevelopmental disorders is also more prone to physical conditions and functional labilities with impairments [16]. Mental lability in disposition is manifested as having mood and anxiety disorders, disruptive behavior disorders, and when older, substance use disorders [17]. The lability set should be better viewed as involving the interdependent brain-body, as the dynamic and complex brain is tightly coupled and integrated with the rest of the body as a self-organized system [18]. Phenotypes are shifted towards having the atypical features of ASD, with phenotypic diversity of ASD symptoms and impairments and with variabilities in autistic traits [19,20]. Environment takes a certain role [21,22]. With the heritability of ASD being between 64 and 91% [23] and estimates never reaching well above 90% [24] even with concordant MZ twins, it suggests a role for non-shared effects such as epigenetic, gene expression, other environmental and/or stochastic factors [25,26]. Environmental effects from air pollutants [27-30] and valproic acid [31] in pregnancy are well noted. While most would tend to agree that autism is caused by a combination of genetics and the environment, there is no specific dominant causation environment.
Genes relating to neurodevelopment could have effects on synapse formation, neuronal proliferation, growth, transcription and splicing, and chromatin remodeling [32-34]. While these shapes the neural pathways by molecular convergence and specificity towards certain patterns of neuro-connectivity, biased gene sets activated prenatally at developmental “windows” are open to the environment. The final neurobiological architecture has certain lability in disposition. Genes for the individual to react with microbiota may even be affected. Among gene mutations most widely associated with ASD are mutations in genes related to the mTOR pathway [35], which apart from its important role in neurological disorders, is also involved in directing immune responses. ASD-risk factors such as advanced parental age [36,37], low birth weight [38] and multiple births [39] may be related to, at the body core of ASD individuals, their related immune changes, as well as the whole lability in disposition. Related to deviations in gut microbiota [40,41], brain reactions and neuroinflammation are seen early even since pregnancy [42,43]. Neuroimmune changes in ASD [44] would further enhance core lability, resulting in many functional problems. As immunological dysregulation is not necessarily correlated with the severity of autistic traits [45], it could be more a sign of core lability. The state of the gut and its microbiota priming immune and metabolic functions have a long-lasting modification for developing several physical conditions, including gastrointestinal, allergic, autoimmune, and metabolic diseases [46] as a kind of altered adaptive neuro-immune function. Maladaptive functional GI problems are particularly common in ASD [47,48].
This bias of autistic individuals towards formation of a labile core, being prejudiced by postnatal gut microbiome on the brain as well as by mental edging labilities from genetic makeup, could have subsequent lifetime effects on the development of a full-blown ASD. Each phase of neurodevelopment would produce a set of neurological and somatic base for the next phase of development cascading onto further neuropsychological functions [49-51] along with the common highway of neuro-developmental processes, with the many genetic and environmental biological as drivers building up the ASD makeup (Figure 1).
Figure 1: The Genetic and Microbiome Setup towards the ASD mal-development. The genetic setup converges to cause brain pathways causing perturbations in neurodevelopment in utero. The genes affect neural pathways starting mid fetal life. Probably earlier than this is the period of migration of immune stem cells and expansion of progenitor cells. Then, maternal microbiota is associated with ASD development. A labile body core is developed consequent from the genetic setup related to other mental-neurodevelopmental disorders and to body immune and neuroimmune perturbations. This labile core features impaired matching capabilities in infancy, and body functional problems especially marked in the intestine. Related autistic atypicalities of repetitive behaviors and disturbed emotion-guided attention started, even manifesting as emotion-evasive behavior, social guardedness, food selectivity, food intolerance and food allergy occur in the body-brain domain, while poor development of self-relevance, poor neuro connectivity to large scale brain network occur in the brain-body domain. ASD symptoms and signs become more obvious after infancy .
ASD
certainly develop early [52]. However, characterizing
behavioral signs are not present early
in life and do not emerge until the second year [53], even after
attention to subtle representations of autistic traits [54]. Rather than simply genetics forming a
dysfunctional 'social brain network' [55,56],
ASD individuals start with atypical development in early life involving
perceptual, attentional, motor, and social systems before the emerging autism
phenotype [53].
The margins
in developing ASD during postnatal development [6] may be related to
core capacity and matching capabilities that influence the fully developed
formation [57], as environment and
energy/resources provision as well as individual potential and self-regulatory
setup allow for internal and external remodeling.
The
genetic convergence on synapse formation, neuronal proliferation, growth,
transcription and splicing, and chromatin remodeling is one part of the starter
processes. With general vulnerability prone to mental-neurodevelopmental
disorders and starting additionally with influence from deviations in gut
microbiota, the body is labile and prone to both mental and physical conditions
and functional labilities including intestinal and immunological dysregulation.
These
physical conditions include gastro-intestinal (GI) dysfunction [58], functional psychogenic abdominal pain in children [59], migraine and primary
headaches [60], learning disabilities, attention deficit disorder [61] and sleep problems
[62].
Physical and mental
processes together on the developmental highway contribute to
an aberrant trajectory. There are certainly some
atypicalities to start with, yet none singly can account for ASD to develop.
Furthermore, oddly for determinists, ASD is not a fixed outcome. The outcome is
related to vulnerability to a spectrum of traits: the biological mechanisms
being associated with vulnerability starts early in life, to be shaped by
postnatal drivers [63]. The final
manifestations can be heterogeneous. In fact, at best ASD diagnosis requires a
co-aggregate whole [64] or a gestalt [65].
On the highway for
this aberrant developmental trajectory, parts contribute to the whole [7]. In this complex disorder, the patterned behavior, the shaped internal
patterns in functioning, the stored memory, the further adaptive re-tuning, and
the microbiota–gut–brain axis, all exert a profound influence on key brain
processes [7]. Not simply a "social brain" pathology to
explain for the social development in ASD [53,57], not singly a
hippocampal perturbation to explain for ASD memory function impairment [66]. ASDs develop from widespread brain atypicalities, remodeling for
internal and external dysmaturation as well as biased emotive or motive
activities [7]. In fact, with
multiple parts that contribute to ASD, it is not so surprising to see such
report that the frequency and severity of nausea and vomiting during pregnancy
can affect ASD severity [67].
Early complexity developmental rings
Manifested
impairments start early with impaired visuomotor weaknesses from subtle
proprioceptive and integration-coordination matching problems associated with a
labile core [68-70]. The drivers
are subtly perturbed. Many seem just functional. Joint attention ability is
atypical in ASD, rather than simply being delayed [71,72]. Visuomotor
coordinative setup is essential for matching in real time [73]. The worse the onset profile of exteroceptive dysfunction, the more would be
the ASD development and abnormal social communication [74].
Dispositional
tendencies are ill framed by the labile core and its functional problems as
well as by memory mechanisms that are impaired in ASD. The hippocampus expands
rapidly in the first two years of life [75], developing at
the age when gut development and microbiota are established as visceral
sensations and the enteric nervous system develop together. The
hippocampus is activated by enteric signals through the vagus nerve between the
intestinal tract and the brain [76]. The vagus itself mediates GI-sensory signaling to dorsal hippocampal
glutamatergic neurons, facilitates hippocampal neurogenesis [77], and promotes
hippocampal-dependent learning and memory function [78]. Functional GI disorders start early. At
the same time, the insula cortex, as it expands rapidly in the first year of
life, may be perturbed by interoceptive or visceral sensations that it maps.
During
development, exteroceptive and interoceptive functions progress and advance
together. The body modules,
each as subsystems supporting specific functions, are mutually interacting
dynamically. Programmed organization upon programmed
organization will be reinforced through repeated use and developed further,
while social, emotional, and cognitive brain domains develop in parallel.
Functional gut dysfunction would have consequent internal resource handling
problems. Energy and glucose metabolism are associated with and regulation
products can affect synaptic function [79].
Visuomotor impairment and subtle proprioceptive
problems causing matching and lateralization disturbances with problems in multisensory
integration, impaired chaining abilities and joint-attention behavior, even
with low attention to faces and a salience bias (Figure 2).
The salience to act in a multi-stimuli environment
is further limited by internal resource functioning needed to simultaneously
process sensory input. The poorer emotional valence as emotion-guided attention in ASD children [80] is
associated with high levels of autistic traits [81]. When grown up, ASD adults [82,83] or
those neurotypical adults with high level of autistic traits [84]
have the response flattened, not differing. It could be related to the
insufficiency of resources in childhood in ASD for salient attention with
multiply increased demand for efforts to cater for the many stimuli, getting
better in resource allocation and compensated when they grow older [7].
Variations in infants for saliency by attention
allocation to their visual social environment [85,86] affect their active shaping
of their own visual experiences and development [87]. The affected
individual may be obsessed with social visual engagement in the individual’s
own ecological niche or becomes emotionally evading to reduce his inherent risk
and adversity by active construction and maintenance of an ecological niche for
himself that mediates social attachment. Emotion guided attention is dampened.
Reduced salience in attention may bring along many sensory modalities
being affected. Sensory processing
problems are noted later mainly after 2 years of age [88-90], affecting any sensory modality [91] with no one modality uniquely a hallmark for ASD [92]. ASD individuals commonly
exhibit inflexible behavior and fixated interests. In terms of capabilities,
some are innately limited, and some are functionally capped. Atypical brain
prediction errors may maintain behavioral and cognitive inflexibility and
rigidity in ASD [93-95]. Sometimes, as gaps need be overcome, enhanced attention to
details is common, and visual
search in ASD would be enhanced and even becomes robustly efficient as an area
of strength in ASD [96].
ASD children have comparatively reduced attention and memory for self-relevant objects [97,98]. Social reward from the self-relevant responses of others is less rewarding for adults with ASD [99]. Reward processing deficits [100] correlate with overall ASD symptom severity [101]. Full reward not really achieved, and resource functional suboptimal, autistic tendencies with dampened emotion-guided attention [80] evolve into emotion-evaded behavior. Impaired memory mechanisms, and functional gut problems with interoceptive-exteroceptive maladjustment and feelings further shape the emotional inclination.
Figure 2: Rings on rings of
atypical development with consequent dysfunctional processes.
To
recapitulate, impairments first through primary with genetic adaptive mental
edging labilities and perturbed microbiota-gut-brain axis, develop a labile
body core more prone to both mental and physical conditions and functional
labilities (Ring 1). Impaired matching to environment is a maladjustment
related to impaired visuomotor coordinative setup as well as impaired memory
systems associated with gut-vagal dysfunction and microbiota alterations. These
have interoceptive and extractive consequences feeding back into a salience bias
with poor emotion-guided attention (Ring 2), leading to further secondary
altered internal processes and external behavior. With poor assets of an
inefficient memory mechanism, neuroimmune alterations, gastrointestinal
dysregulation and functional guardedness, the individual could face integration
and adaptive problems for the whole person. The labile core manifest with
atypical eating patterns and food selectivity highly associated with ASD. Food
guardedness may evolve into distaste. Social distaste manifests in time with
on-going reward processing deficits and cumulative atypicalities in behaviors
reacting in an individual predisposed to ASD (Ring 3). After these rings, the
typical ASD may further develop with widespread brain atypicalities while the
social, emotional, and cognitive brain domains are developing at the same time.
The complexity contributed by both physical and mental impairment is analogous
to rings upon rings with organizational consequences upon consequences.
At worst if distastes developed
ASD is highly associated with atypical eating
patterns [102] and food selectivity [103-106]. Rather than gratification from food, the net experience would vary and
ASD children have problems with taste and/or smell sensitivity mealtime
problems [107] and regurgitator reflux commonly [108], all suggesting a reactive
enteric nervous system with functional guardedness of the GI system.
Along with food guardedness or defensiveness, even
tactile “defensiveness” associated with food selectivity has been reported [102,107,109] in children with ASD. Even their skin conductance changes could change
with emotional stimuli such as when presented with defense to faces feared [110]. Along with food repulsion and selectivity, food allergies are observed
more often in autistic individuals than in the general population [111-113].
Social distaste is not an
early primer. Poor social reward and retrieval-related memory impairments
additionally drift the child’s development gradually into social distaste. Only
with the on-going cumulative atypicalities in behaviors reacting in an
individual genetically predisposed to ASD would it evolve and fully manifests
in time (Figure 2, Ring 3). Layer upon layer, the rings on rings of
maladjustments impair matching capabilities, starting early with visuomotor
coordination impairment, suboptimal resource functioning, guarded food
selectivity, related defensive behavior, atypical reward-seeking behavior, and
self-stimulatory drives depending on severity. More atypicalities may be derived
and evolve further with related guarded social behavior, altered emotion-guided
attention in ASD children that may evolve into emotion-evading behaviors, and
altered self-relevant reward system that dampens the rewarding nature of social
interaction and cognition.
With the deranged make-up
of ASD set for development (from the microbiota-gut-brain axis, the
gut-vagus-hippocampus axis, and the brain-social-cognitive axis) [7],
as the individual adapts to the environment, the regional and large-scale brain
networks become atypical and build up significant cascading effects on
neuropsychological development to form the whole ASD problem. Rings on rings
of maladjustment trajectory screw in, and the end can be complex and
heterogeneous.
Guardedness may accentuate
and the poor social-reward system could bring up further secondary consequences
with altered internal and external processes and behavior, with the characteristic ASD impairments in social
development—stereotypical behavior, communication, and social interaction
deficits. Deviated mode and different salient whole may manifest as more
calculative rational [114]. With problems
in processing
information about the “self” and self-relevance, the salience network, and the default
mode network (DMN) that mature in later childhood would be drifted into dysregulation or delay and dysmaturation. ASD has
dysmaturation of the DMN with relatively late DMN maturation and still under-connected [115-118] to achieve the
typical cross-network connectivity [119,120]. Insula
activation is also involved and reduced in ASD during social processing [121]. These are associated with
alterations in social cognition that are characteristic of ASD [122].
The former multiple neural substrates affected
along the highway of neurodevelopment, drive the individual into certain ways
of behaving and attention, and mold emotion-guided behavior into dysfunctional
processes, which during long-term establishment could lead to secondary
deranged cerebral connectivity. Altered variations in saliency, skimping away
from poor allocation of resource functioning, social distaste, food distaste
with food allergies as worse scenario for ASD can be among the atypical
development involving multiple systems including perceptual, emotional,
attentional, motor, and social systems that precede the emerging autism
phenotype [7]. By this time,
large-scale brain network is at fault, not a single regional pathology.
Complex problems are
related to multiple causes each with small but pertinent effects that work
together additively or synergistically to affect a significant perturbation.
ASDs, mainly contributed by common genetic variants in the population, affect
individuals with drastically varying phenotypes even with similar genetic
variants. As the parts contribute to the whole, after deeper detailed
understanding of the parts [7], the full
picture how the parts click into each other would manifest.
The increase of mental as well as physical
conditions and functional impairments in ASD individuals, the increase
risk for immune dysregulation, GI
disturbances, and neurologic-psychogenic problems [123,124], and sleep problems in an individual, all predict more severe behavioral
symptoms in ASD children [125]. They correlate with atypical eating patterns starting early in life [106],
food selectivity [126] and associated atypical
oral sensory sensitivity [123], even defensive-refusal mechanisms as gastroesophageal reflux disorder
in childhood [108] in a form of body-brain dysregulation with functional psychogenic
abdominal pain associated with irritability, social withdrawal, stereotypy,
hyperactivity, or inappropriate speech [127], and internalizing symptoms
[128-130].
Both mental and physical atypicalities contribute
to ASD [128-130]. While initially genetically predisposed, all these in a child
develop with widespread brain atypicalities and neuro-connectivity related to
exteroceptive and interoceptive dysfunction as a co-aggregate sprouting from
rings on rings of impairments [7]. The individual outcome in development will be
determined by his biological setup of genetic program modulated by epigenetic
forces and by engrained patterns over recurrent contexts of the physicochemical
and biosocial environment. Then the whole can be mapped more clearly. Postnatal
margin for therapy is there.